Judge grants part of Roy Suryo's fifth pretrial motion
Jakarta (ANTARA) - The South Jakarta District Court has ruled to partially grant Roy Suryo’s fifth pretrial motion concerning his claim for compensation of Rp206 million.
“On the merits, the applicant’s pretrial motion is granted in part,” said Sole Judge I Ketut Darpawan when reading out the verdict at the South Jakarta District Court on Tuesday.
In its ruling, the judge ordered Co-Respondent II, who is the Minister of Finance of the Republic of Indonesia, to pay compensation. In this case, authority was granted to the Head of the Advocacy Bureau of the Ministry of Finance, Rofii Edy Purnomo.
The judge stated that this is stipulated in Articles 10 and 11 of Government Regulation Number 92 of 2015, which govern compensation payments made by the minister responsible for government affairs in the financial sector, based on an extract of a court verdict or order.
“Compensation payments shall be made by the minister responsible for government affairs in the financial sector based on an extract of a court verdict or order,” said Darpawan.
“Awarding immaterial damages to the Applicant amounting to Rp5 million. Ordering Co-Respondent II to pay compensation of Rp5 million to the Applicant,” said Darpawan.
The judge considered immaterial damages to be part of the losses that may be claimed by a person who has been unlawfully arrested and detained.
This, he said, is based on Article 173 paragraph (1) of the Criminal Procedure Code, which gives a suspect, defendant or convict the right to claim compensation if arrested, detained, prosecuted, tried or subjected to other actions without lawful grounds based on legislation.
Furthermore, the judge took into account the provisions of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which has been ratified through Law Number 12 of 2005. According to him, compensation for unlawful arrest or detention covers both financial and non-financial losses.
“A nominal limitation must not be interpreted in such a way as to eliminate the right to claim immaterial damages,” said Darpawan.
However, in its ruling, the judge did not grant all of Roy Suryo’s arguments regarding the immaterial losses he claimed, which amounted to Rp100 million. Roy Suryo argued that these losses arose because he suffered psychological burdens, anxiety, attacks on his honour, and social stigma as a result of media coverage related to the case against him.
“Considering that Article 173 paragraph (1) of the Criminal Procedure Code stipulates that a suspect, defendant or convict has the right to claim compensation because they were arrested, detained, prosecuted, tried or subjected to other actions without lawful grounds based on legislation, or because of an error regarding the person or the law applied. The Criminal Procedure Code does not limit the type of losses that may be claimed, whether only material or immaterial losses,” explained Darpawan.
The judge then considered the errors made by investigators during the search and arrest. These were declared unlawful due to formal and material defects.
“And the detention was declared unlawful because it did not meet the subjective requirements as considered in Decision Number 99, and taking into account the fact of the length of time the defendant was held in unlawful coercive measures, namely for four days, as well as the impact of the stigma experienced by the Applicant while under such coercive measures, as considered above, the Judge awards immaterial damages amounting to Rp5 million,” said Darpawan.
Roy Suryo is known to have filed pretrial motions five times. The first pretrial motion concerned the search, arrest and detention. That claim was granted in part.
Roy Suryo subsequently lost in three other pretrial motions.
Roy Suryo’s fifth pretrial motion, registered today under case number 149/Pid.Pra/2026/PN JKT.SEL, named Polda Metro Jaya, the Jakarta High Prosecutor’s Office and the Ministry of Finance as respondents.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judge-grants-part-of-roy-suryos-fifth-pretrial-motion-1789462689)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5741844/hakim-kabulkan-sebagian-praperadilan-kelima-roy-suryo), translated from Indonesian