Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Judge Grants Part of Roy Suryo's Fifth Pre-Trial Claim for Compensation

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Judge Grants Part of Roy Suryo's Fifth Pre-Trial Claim for Compensation
Image: detikcom

The South Jakarta District Court (PN Jaksel) has partly granted the fifth pre-trial petition filed by Roy Suryo concerning compensation of Rp 206 million. The respondents in the case were Polda Metro Jaya, the Jakarta Prosecutor’s Office, and the Ministry of Finance.

“In the principal matter, the court grants the applicant’s pre-trial petition in part,” said sole judge I Ketut Darpawan while reading out the verdict at the South Jakarta District Court on Tuesday (15/9/2026).

The judge ordered the Second Co-Respondent, namely the Minister of Finance of the Republic of Indonesia, to pay compensation. In this case, authority is delegated to the Head of the Legal Affairs Bureau at the Ministry of Finance.

The judge stated that the compensation is stipulated under Articles 10 and 11 of Government Regulation Number 92 of 2015. According to the judge, these articles govern the payment of compensation by the minister responsible for government affairs in the financial sector based on court verdicts or rulings.

“The payment of compensation is carried out by the minister responsible for government affairs in the financial sector based on the official extract of a court verdict or ruling,” the judge said in reading out the considerations.

The judge found that the Ministry of Finance has an obligation to make the compensation payment under applicable regulations, even though the eternal fund mechanism under the new Criminal Procedure Code does not yet have complete implementing rules. The judge set the immaterial compensation at Rp 5 million.

“To set immaterial compensation for the applicant amounting to Rp 5 million. To order the Second Co-Respondent to pay compensation amounting to Rp 5 million to the applicant,” the judge said.

The judge considered that immaterial compensation forms part of the losses that may be claimed by a person who has been unlawfully arrested and detained. This, the judge said, can be pursued under Article 173 paragraph (1) of the Criminal Procedure Code, which grants suspects, defendants, or convicts the right to claim compensation if they are arrested, detained, prosecuted, tried, or subjected to other actions without lawful grounds under the law.

The judge’s next consideration was the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which has been ratified through Law Number 12 of 2005. According to the judge, compensation for unlawful arrest or detention covers both financial and non-financial losses.

“A limitation on the amount must not be interpreted in such a way as to eliminate the right to claim immaterial compensation,” the judge explained.

The judge did not grant the entirety of Roy Suryo’s claim regarding immaterial damages, for which he had sought Rp 100 million. Roy Suryo argued that he suffered the losses because he experienced psychological burdens, anxiety, attacks on his honour, and social stigma as a result of news coverage of the case against him.

“Considering that Article 173 paragraph (1) of the Criminal Procedure Code stipulates that a suspect, defendant, or convict has the right to claim compensation for being arrested, detained, prosecuted, tried, or subjected to other actions without lawful grounds under the law, or due to an error regarding the person or the law applied. The Criminal Procedure Code does not limit the type of losses that may be claimed, whether only material or immaterial,” the judge said.

The judge found that Roy Suryo’s status as a public figure, a former minister, and a former member of the House of Representatives cannot serve as the basis for determining the level of psychological burden he experienced. The judge said that psychological conditions must be proven through expert examination in order to be accountable.

The judge took into account the errors concerning the search and arrest, which had previously been declared unlawful in an earlier pre-trial petition.

“The detention was declared unlawful because it did not meet the subjective requirements as considered in Decision Number 99, and taking into account the fact of the length of time the applicant was subjected to unlawful coercive measures, namely for four days, as well as the impact of the stigma experienced by the applicant while under those coercive measures as considered above, the judge sets the immaterial compensation at Rp 5 million,” the judge said.

Roy Suryo, who is a suspect in the alleged defamation case concerning the diploma of 7th President Joko Widodo (Jokowi), is known to have filed pre-trial challenges five times. The first pre-trial related to the search, arrest, and detention, and that petition was partly granted.

Roy Suryo subsequently lost in three other pre-trial challenges. This fifth petition was registered under case number 149/Pid.Pra/2026/PN JKT.SEL.

More from 15 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judge-grants-part-of-roy-suryos-fifth-pre-trial-claim-for-compensation-1789462526)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8663784/hakim-kabulkan-sebagian-praperadilan-kelima-roy-suryo-soal-ganti-rugi), translated from Indonesian
Print