Judge Again Rebukes Dr Tifa’s Lawyer: ‘Be Quiet or Leave!’
The trial of Tifauzia Tyassuma, also known as Dr Tifa, on a defamation charge became heated while former Indonesian president Joko Widodo (Jokowi) was giving evidence. The judge reprimanded Tifa’s lawyer and told him to be quiet or leave the courtroom.
The hearing was held at the East Jakarta District Court on Thursday (5 November 2026). Prosecutors initially sought to present a report from the National Police’s Criminal Investigation Laboratory (Puslabfor) concerning Jokowi’s diploma.
Tifa’s lawyer objected, saying he had not received the report. The prosecutor urged the lawyer to distinguish between evidence and physical exhibits.
“Your Honour, we wish to present the report from the National Police’s Criminal Investigation Laboratory concerning the diploma shown earlier,” the prosecutor said.
“Your Honour, we have not received that report,” Tifa’s lawyer said.
“You haven’t?” the judge asked.
“No, we object, Your Honour,” the lawyer replied.
The prosecutor told Tifa’s lawyer to submit a request for the laboratory findings. The prosecutor denied that the findings had been withheld, saying they were being presented at the hearing.
“As we said earlier, Sir, this is not a physical exhibit. It is the same as a statement of examination, Sir. It is documentary evidence. We are showing it, not explaining it; we are not experts. Earlier we heard the question of how we determined whether it was genuine or fake: ‘Where is the laboratory report?’ We are producing it now. It is in our indictment, Sir. This is not a physical exhibit; it is evidence,” the prosecutor said.
Tifa’s lawyer asked for the laboratory report to be handed over to him. A dispute followed, with the prosecutor and lawyer trading arguments.
“Your Honour, may we continue? Thank you. Your Honour, I would also like to point out that Article 235(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code lists several forms of evidence, including documents and physical exhibits. If counsel cannot distinguish between them, that is not our fault,” the prosecutor said.
“Your Honour! I also want to read out a provision. Article 150(j) of Law No. 20 on the Criminal Procedure Code gives lawyers the right to request documents and evidence. My question is: is that a document or not?” Tifa’s lawyer responded.
Tifa’s lawyer said he agreed to submit a formal request for the laboratory findings, and asked for the hearing to be adjourned until the request had been made.
“Your Honour! We agree to submit a request. Since we have not done so, please adjourn the hearing until we submit it. If that is what is required, we ask for an adjournment and will file the request,” the lawyer said.
The judge said the hearing would continue and rejected the lawyer’s objection to proceeding.
“We will continue the hearing. I reject your objection and will proceed,” the judge said.
“Isn’t that contrary to this law?” the lawyer asked.
“You may make a request. There is no requirement that you do so beforehand. If you wish to study it and make a request, you may. This will be presented, and an expert will also be called,” the judge said.
The lawyer continued to put forward his arguments. The judge warned him that he could leave or remain silent if he did not wish to follow the proceedings.
“You may object. We will continue the hearing. If you are not going to follow it, you may leave,” the judge said.
“That can’t be right,” Tifa’s lawyer replied.
“Your Honour, may we continue?” the prosecutor interjected.
“Your Honour! We have already—” the lawyer began.
“The hearing will continue. You may be quiet or leave. Please,” the judge said.
The prosecutor tried to resume questioning Jokowi, but Tifa’s lawyer continued speaking. The judge ordered that the hearing proceed with the prosecutor’s questions.
“I will no longer accept comments from there. We will continue the hearing,” the judge said.
“We have already submitted a letter…” the lawyer interjected.
“This is an order,” the judge rebuked him.
“We have submitted a letter, Your Honour,” the lawyer said.
“Enough. Continue,” the judge insisted.
“The request for the report to be handed over is in writing. It has been received by the South Jakarta District Prosecutor’s Office. The person who received it at the time was…” the lawyer said, before being interrupted.
“If that needs to be stopped, deal with it later. Please continue. This is disrupting order. It has already been addressed,” the judge said.
The prosecutor then read out the laboratory report on Jokowi’s diploma. According to the prosecutor, the findings said the document was identical to the comparison documents, or was produced using the same printing process.
“Based on Criminalistics Laboratory Examination Report No. Lab 4578/DCF/2025, dated 7 October 2025, the comparison examination of one exhibit—an Universitas Gadjah Mada Faculty of Forestry diploma, number 1120, in the name of Joko Widodo—with 14 comparison diplomas concluded that it was identical to the comparison documents or was a product of the same printing process,” the prosecutor said.
“Your Honour, that is sufficient; we have read out the main point. We will explain the examination procedures and methods by calling an expert,” the prosecutor added.
Tifa faces multiple charges. The primary charge alleges a violation of Article 434(1) in conjunction with Article 441(1) of Law No. 1 of 2023 on the Criminal Code. The subsidiary charge alleges a violation of Article 433(1) in conjunction with Article 441(1) of the same law.
Prosecutors have also charged Tifa under Article 32 in conjunction with Article 48(1) of Law No. 11 of 2008 on Electronic Information and Transactions (ITE), in conjunction with Law No. 1 of 2026 on Criminal Penalty Adjustments.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judge-again-rebukes-dr-tifas-lawyer-be-quiet-or-leave-1793893907)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8740397/hakim-lagi-lagi-tegur-pengacara-dr-tifa-diam-atau-keluar), translated from Indonesian