Despite weak law enforcement, RI stocks shine
Despite weak law enforcement, RI stocks shine
Rendi A. Witular
The Jakarta Post/Jakarta
The Jakarta stock market made headlines in the nation's media
nearly every week this year with its record-high trading
activities, which also made it one of the best performers in the
world.
Yet, analysts and industry players are still concerned over
the weak law enforcement demonstrated by market authorities.
The Jakarta Composite Index shifted into full-throttle on Jan.
9 when it leaped by 22.877 points, or 3.1 percent, to 752.692,
the highest rise since the benchmark was initiated in 1982. It
also recorded an all-time high of Rp 1.99 trillion (US$221
million) during that day's trading.
Analysts said the surge was fueled mainly by an inflow of
capital from new investors in the United States and Europe,
taking advantage of growing market capitalization -- usually,
only Asian investors are interested in Indonesian stocks.
U.S. and European investors entered the bourse for the promise
of large gains in capitalizing on the stock market, given that
many Jakarta stocks were relatively cheaper than others in the
region.
Fueled by the unexpected trouble-free general elections, which
saw the country's first direct presidential election, the Index
charged forward, breaking the record 800 level in mid-September
and hitting the 900 level in early November.
During the first 11 months of 2004, the Index rose by more
than 35 percent overall.
Chairman of the Indonesian Securities Firms Association (APEI)
Noor Hasyim said the Jakarta stock market had a "golden year",
and many people suddenly found themselves nouveau millionaires
due to the soaring trade in the bourse.
"Optimism over the country's economic growth and over the new
government under President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono has made the
Index stronger," said Noor, also managing director of Bank Negara
Indonesia Securities.
He said the market responded positively to the new government,
which has pledged to combat the chronic corruption within the
administration and to improve the dwindling business climate so
that the country could regain its competitiveness.
The improving profitability of listed companies amid
increasing macroeconomic stability has also lured investors to
stocks.
However, other analysts believed the rally in the Index was
caused primarily by the intervention of the previous and current
governments to help create an image that the business community
had great confidence in them.
Another objective was to procure good prices for the
government's plan to sell some of its equity in a number of
publicly listed companies.
Some analysts have suggested that such rallies were driven
partly by state pension funds and insurance companies, which are
being ordered to pump funds into the market.
Despite the positive news thus far, some investors are wary
about continued good performance.
"We expect the authorities to improve law enforcement
significantly next year, to provide legal certainty so more
domestic investors and companies will be attracted to investing
in the stock market," said Noor.
He said the Capital Market Supervisory Agency (Bapepam) --
which should have been at the forefront in pushing all parties to
honor the law -- had often ignored capital market rules and the
principles of good governance.
Weak law enforcement is evident in the fact that no market
violation has been taken to court, and because the market
watchdog has been tough on only small or less well-connected
firms, but has dared only to impose small fines on well-connected
firms in case of regulatory violations.
Many may remember how Bapepam sparked criticism with its March
announcement that it had found no proof that traders had
deliberately driven up the share price of Bank Internasional
Indonesia (BII) last year for personal gains, ahead of the
government's plan to sell 17.43 percent of its BII stake to
public investors.
However, Bapepam acknowledged the existence of "procedural
violations", and imposed a Rp 1 billion fine on Transpacific
Securindo, which was actively involved in BII share trading
during the three months leading up to the stake sale.
Bapepam was also criticized for merely imposing a financial
fine on state-owned pharmaceutical firm PT Indofarma over
disinformation in its financial report.
The firm's former management was accused of intentionally
overstating the firm's assets, sales and net profit for its 2001
financial report.
Bapepam later fined the management Rp 28.9 billion for failing
to apply proper accounting practices, but to the disappointment
of many observers of good corporate governance, it dropped
possible criminal charges against Indofarma.
Bapepam and the Jakarta Stock Exchange (JSX) management have
been criticized for their impotence in dealing with certain big-
name companies such as PT Telkom and cement producer PT Semen
Gresik: While Telkom and Semen Gresik were only threatened with
minor penalties for their failure to submit financial reports on
time, market authorities threatened to delist smaller firms for
the same failure.
In addition, market authorities were unwilling to take stern
action against PT Bukaka Teknik Utama, an engineering firm linked
to the family of Vice President Jusuf Kalla, even though it had
violated capital market regulations.
In July, before many had begun to anticipate that Kalla would
be vice president, the JSX announced that it would delist Bukaka
along with Texmaco Perkasa Engineering, plastic producer PT
Wahana Jaya Perkasa and infrastructure firm PT Siswani Makmur.
The bourse said the delisting plan was based on the suspension
of Bukaka shares for over a year following difficulties in its
business operations, and because of a "disclaimer" from the
company's auditor, Ernst & Young, on its financial performance
over four consecutive years.
However, the plan was dropped in September, as the Bukaka
operation was considered sustainable and because the bourse would
extend its listing period to give some time for the company to
undergo restructuring.
The JSX management later said it would prevent the delisting
of any public companies, claiming the action would only bring
losses to investors and benefit troubled companies.
Economist Faisal Basri said tough punishment should become the
foundation of market discipline, as poor law enforcement was the
main deterrent against big companies listing their shares or
against prominent global investors from pouring more investment
into the bourse, Faisal said.
"Bapepam officials have often tried to protect market
violators from heavy punishment..., " said Faisal, who is also an
executive of monopoly watchdog KPPU, the Business Competition
Supervisory Commission.
By enforcing market laws and regulations fairly and
consistently, and so exciting investors to channel new capital
into local stocks, the bourse may just find that this year's
shining performance was merely the tip of the iceberg.
More from 25 December 2004 โ
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/jpren-1447899208-1464011)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post