Money talks in April ballot printing projects
Money talks in April ballot printing projects
Moch. N. Kurniawan
Jakarta
Officials of the General Elections Commission (KPU) argued in
April that they lacked the funds to better educate the public on
how to cast their votes in the legislative election, which may in
part explain the invalid votes reaching some 9 percent (almost 11
million) of 125 million votes. This was one among many flaws that
the KPU sought to correct ahead of the presidential election on
July 5.
However, over the last few months, it has been suggested that
limited funding was not to blame. Negligence was cited upon
closer observation of the recruitment of printing firms -- not to
mention suspected corruption and collusion. This could explain
the possible loss to the state of billions of rupiah, which the
KPU desperately needed, in so many areas, to orchestrate the
elections.
In the area of ballot printing for the April legislative
election, a senior executive of a winning company said later that
they had to provide "fees" to KPU officials in charge of ballot
printing even after the commission had made public the results of
the poll.
The executive, who requested anonymity, said extra fees were
necessary to speed up the payment process from the KPU for the
printing job.
"Just give those in charge of the ballot printing extra money,
it is common," he said, but did not reveal the sum that exchanged
hands.
A broker from another firm found to have subcontracted its
printing job, also acknowledged that money was involved in
speeding up the tender process.
"It is common practice to speed up the red tape with money in
this country. Nobody can deny it," he told The Jakarta Post.
The broker said that he was merely aiding the printing firm he
represented in order to win a tender.
Earlier, another executive of a winning printing company
stressed that he had given hundreds of millions of rupiah to
those in charge of the ballot paper tender.
According to him, all bidding printing firms had three
approaches for lobbying their case -- KPU members, its KPU
secretariat and its logistics bureau.
KPU member Malign W. Kusumah, who chaired the ballot paper
printing tender, said he had not observed any officials acting
with an intent to strike a deal with printing firms and so help
them win the tenders.
He conceded that the commission was unable to check all 17
winning firms and their facilities, as they were understaffed and
short of time.
He also stressed that the ballot paper committee had taken
full responsibility for all decisions it took at that time.
Firms bidding in KPU tenders also tried to outdo their
competition by manipulating the data they submitted to the
commission on printing firms.
An investigation by the Post revealed that
at least six of the 17 companies that won the KPU's printing
project did not have the appropriate machines and set a high
printing cost.
The KPU picked 17 firms to print the 660 million ballot papers
for the April 5 election. Its final selection was, however, based
on documented machine specifications submitted by tender
participants, and the commission did not conduct any field
checks.
The documents only stated that those printing firms that had
met tender requirements and the KPU's prices were declared
winners.
Many tender winners, however, were unable to meet their
printing deadlines, causing a delay in the distribution of ballot
papers. In some areas, the KPU had to delay the elections due to
the late arrival of election materials, such as ballots and ink.
To prevent a repeat experience, the KPU decided to appoint
printing companies directly for the July 5 presidential election.
Regarding the possibility of overpricing, KPU tender
consultant Sentot Marjuki has said the commission had conducted
its own calculations that resulted in a price of Rp 275 for six
colors -- or Rp 45.8 per color -- for printing ballots of between
40 cm x 65 cm to 55 cm x 80.5 cm, or "plano" size, and that the
KPU's price was low.
However, several winning companies said they could print six-
color ballots for Rp 150 to Rp 180, or Rp 25 to Rp 30 per color.
The cost of printing 660 million ballots, according to the
KPU's figure of Rp 275 each, would be Rp 184 billion.
If, instead, the price was Rp 180 each -- the highest figure
mentioned by the above companies -- the cost would be some Rp
120.5 billion. Thus, potential losses to the state amount to Rp
63.5 billion.
The KPU, according to observers, has the crucial attribute of
being trusted by the public at large; its members, whom are
mostly university lecturers, may be regarded as inexperienced --
but not corrupt. A further probe into the recruitment of printing
firms would help ensure that that trust is maintained.
--------------------------------------------------------------
Findings on ballot firms
--------------------------------------------------------------
1. Winkarya Lintas Persada
- Printer specification listed as 4-color, but a check
revealed it to be 2-color
- Submitted price of Rp 25 per color for 6-color ballots
2. Dwi Rama
- Printer specs listed as 4-color, but check revealed it
was not a color printer
3. Jenakarya Adi Indah
- under specifications for printers and price, it had
entered: "refer to PT Nusantara Lestari"
4. Balai Pustaka
- stated that it only accepted print orders for books
5. Pebea Tata Mandiri
- corporate address leads to a residential house
6. Swadharma (under Peruri group bid)
- noted it would only accept orders on condition that it
would supply the plain paper
--------------------------------------------------------------
Source: The Jakarta Post
The above report was made possible with the support of the
Coalition for a Free and Fair Election.
The writer is a journalist of The Jakarta Post.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/jpiwacd-1447899208-1505000)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post