Moral teaching in Indonesian schools needs reinforcement
Moral teaching in Indonesian
schools needs reinforcement
Simon Marcus Gower
Principal
Harapan Bangsa High School
Tangerang
Banten
Fighting on the streets of Jakarta. Gangs of youths running
rampage. Stones are thrown and windows broken. Baton wielding
frenzied fighters beating on each other. Traffic brought to a
standstill as combatants chase each other across city streets.
What is happening here? Is it anarchy? Some demonstration that
has become unruly? No, the freqent scenes are those of high
school students engaged in a violent conflict, the root of which
is ignorance, pettiness or some foolish misunderstanding.
What is it that allows high school students to so easy resort
to violence? Certainly there are fights in and between schools
all over the world but rarely does one see students recklessly
endangering members of the public as seems to happen in Jakarta.
Perhaps these students have become used to the sight of
violence on the streets -- but it may be that the education
system is failing to instill within these students the values and
discipline that would make such violence offensive and outside of
their consideration.
Take the notion of discipline within schools in Indonesia. It
is clear that the manner in which discipline is targeted in
Indonesia is far more along the lines of humiliation than it is
education. Rules are rigidly laid down and should anyone
transgress against those rules they will face humiliation.
A few recent examples: A student who had been late once too
often was ordered to stand outside his classroom for the whole
school day, but -- to stand with nothing on his feet and on one
leg. Should he be caught not standing on one leg,
the time of his punishment would be extended.
Next, two students that the teacher complained of talking in
class were ordered to run around the school premises for one hour
-- in the heat of the midday sun. And a boy who had allowed his
hair to grow beyond the regulation length summarily had his head
shaved by a teacher in front of the rest of the school.
These are not the policies or tactics of a thoughtful or
caring school system but are rather the kinds of antics one might
reasonably expect to see within a fairly harsh prison.
Establishments aimed at education should not seek to humiliate
anyone, if there is any need to punish. It is far more credible
within the scope of education to propose that where
mistakes or misdemeanors have occurred the educators, first and
foremost, should capitalize on them as an opportunity for the
students to learn and appreciate more appropriate conduct.
They are after all developing adolescents from whom one may
reasonably expect some misdemeanors, not criminals that have to
be punished for their heinous criminality. Within the Indonesian
curricula there are subjects that would allow students to
consider morally and socially acceptable behavior.
The subject of Pendidikan Pancasila dan Kewarganegaraan
(Education on Pancasila and Civics) is one such subject. But
generally it seems the manner in which these subjects are handled
is rather antiquated too. It seems that students are rather
dictatorially told about standards. Rather than showing students
through their general conduct the teachers are forcing rules upon
them. The mentality is that the students must understand and obey
rather than appreciate and chose to respect. Tell a child to do
something and they will likely rebel.
Show them how and they will likely follow. Better to show
rather than to tell. Certain schools are beginning to recognize
and respond to a more modern and responsive need for moral input
into the education system. Some schools now promote their
educational package on the basis that they will and do enter into
"character building" education. This is an interesting and useful
development but again the approach may not be entirely
appropriate.
Some schools designate "character building" as a new subject
for which there is a specific teacher and a specific time slot
within the timetable. This may mean that the notion of "character
building" is prone to become little more than PPKN under another
name. Again this constitutes a misconception of what is required.
There is a real sense in which students should not be forced to
learn about morals or building their characters.
There is a real sense in which teaching morals means little
more than the imposition of rules. "Teaching character" is little
more than a deceit and at best a misnomer. An oxymoron as
character cannot be taught; it has to be developed over time and
from experiences.
Character building, as part of moral education is entirely
reasonable but it has to be realistic and legitimately handled.
Teachers through their daily conduct can have a deep and lasting
input into the morals and character of their students. In
everything that is done, and in every way providing an example of
thoughtfulness and politeness is the best way of helping the
moral education of students.
In seeing how the teachers conduct themselves the students are
being shown an example that they may both consciously and
subconsciously follow. All schools should, then, consider moral
and character driven education but it should come from all
teachers in all subjects. The physical education teacher can
teach good sportsmanship, biology and chemistry teachers can
teach teamwork when working in laboratories, all teachers can
teach respect for property and people as they manage their lesson
time and the classroom.
The need for moral education cannot be denied and should form
a key part of all educators' daily duties. Indonesian society
needs strength in minds and moral strength too. Education's role
in the development of society is great. In terms of moral input
what education can do should be subtle but definite and well
thought out -- to paraphrase a Chinese proverb "it should be as
gradual as the moonrise, perceptible not in progress, but in
result."
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/jp6simon-1447899208-1261610)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post