Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Indonesia needs strong rationale for decentralization

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Indonesia needs strong rationale for decentralization

Muhammad Sauri Hasibuan
Researcher
Fortech
Jakarta

Much of the decentralization which has taken place in the past
decade has been motivated by political concerns. In Latin
America, decentralization has been an essential part of the
democratization process as discredited autocratic central regimes
were replaced by elected governments operating under new
constitutions. In Africa, the spread of multiparty political
systems is creating demand for more local voices in decision-
making. In some countries, such as Ethiopia, decentralization has
already been undertaken.

In the extreme, decentralization represents a desperate
attempt to keep the country together in the face of various
pressures by granting more autonomy to all localities or by
forging federations. A variation on this theme hes been
decentralization as an outcome of prolonged civil wars, such as
in Mozambique and Uganda, where opening political opportunities
at the local levels has allowed for greater participation by all
the former warring factions in the governance of the country.

The transition economies of the former socialist states have
also massively decentralized as the old central apparatus
crumbled. In Indonesia, decentralization has happened in the
absence of any meaningful alternative governance structure to
provide local government services, and it appears to be motivated
by the need to improve service delivery to large populations and
the recognition of the limitations of the central administration.

There are a multitude of design issues that affect the impact
of different types of decentralization on efficiency, equity and
macro stability.

The specific services to be decentralized and the type of
decentralization will depend on economies of scale affecting
technical efficiency and the degree of spillover effects beyond
jurisdictional boundaries.

In the case of Indonesia, significant amounts of money should
be invested to enhance the country's human resource capacity,
especially at the municipal/regency and provincial levels. In
practice, all services do not need to be decentralized in the
same way or to the same degree.

The market is an ultimate form of decentralization in that the
consumer can acquire a tailor-made product from a choice of
suppliers. The nature of most local public services limits this
option and establishes a government role in ensuring the
provision of these services.

Where it is possible to structure competition either in the
delivery of service, or for the right to deliver the service, the
evidence indicates that the service will be delivered more
efficiently. Although uncommon in practice, local governments
have successfully competed for the right to provide certain local
services.

In the array of local public services in any particular
country, a mix of solutions from deconcentration to managed
competition or privatization is likely to co-exist.
Although politics are the driving force behind decentralization
in most countries, fortunately in Indonesia decentralization may
be one of those instances where good politics and good economics
may serve the same end.

The political objectives of increasing political
responsiveness and participation at the local level can coincide
with the economic objectives of better decisions about the use of
public resources and increasing willingness to pay for local
services.

Apart from the enhancement of the capacity-building issue,
each level of the governmental hierarchy in Indonesia should
absorb and fully understand the following five conditions for the
successful implementation of decentralization:

o The decentralization framework must link, at the margins,
local financing and fiscal authority to the service provision
responsibilities and functions of the local government -- so that
local politicians can cover the costs of their decisions and
deliver on their promises.

o The local community must be informed about the costs of
services and service delivery options involved and the resource
envelope and its sources -- so that the decisions they make are
meaningful.

o Officials at all levels should fully understand that the
present organizational arrangement should be reengineered so as
to be able to adapt to constant change brought about by
globalization pressures, and can flexibly move to accommodate
demands from the private sector and the community at large.

o There must be a mechanism by which the community can express
its preferences in a way that it is binding on the politicians so
that there is credible incentive for people to participate;

o There must be a system of accountability that relies on
public and transparent information which enables the community to
effectively monitor the performance of the local government and
react appropriately to that performance -- so that politicians
and local officials have an incentive to be responsive.

To better prepare for implementation, the particular areas
need to undertake policy action research. This research would
need, among other things, to analyze the relevant data and
information on the development experience of the role of the
private sector (notably small and medium enterprises).

Such an examined historical experience would help stakeholders
pass judgments on the beliefs, attitudes, norms and practices
that need to be discarded, and those that need to be reinforced
in the light of future decentralization needs.

More from 19 July 2003 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/jp6sauri-1447899208-1370901)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print