Moving further away from the rule of law
Moving further away
from the rule of law
Ferdinand T. Andi Lolo
Ph.D Student
University of Auckland Law School
New Zealand
We have heard of court rulings which sentenced high ranking
state officials to imprisonment after finding them guilty of
abusing their authority causing substantial financial loss to the
state -- which essentially means misusing the people's money. The
same institution has also sent a homeless man to jail after
finding him guilty of stealing a pair of sandals at a mosque.
All were found guilty and received a prison sentence; however,
the well-connected officials in the corruption cases did not go
to jail because the court did not order them so whereas the poor
fellow in the sandal-stealing case was ordered to serve his term
with immediate effect. We can expect to see more such strange
paradoxes in court rulings.
The rule of law itself is not a law or a rule of the law; it
is a rule about what the law ought to be. It espouses complex and
intertwined values supposedly upheld by society as a whole.
Besides a legal ideal, it is also a political and social ideal.
Although abstract, it can be materialized, in the legal sense, if
the authority and the people accept its supremacy.
There is no provision in the Criminal Code that makes it
imperative for the court to order a convicted criminal offender
to be sent to prison immediately after his or her sentence is
handed down.
Hence such court rulings are perfectly legal. Yet legal is one
thing and just is another. The essence of the rule of law lies in
its principle of justice and not in its legality. Unfortunately,
legal authorities have blurred this crucial difference. Every
policy is measured by its legality or its illegality. Whether
such policy accords the sense of justice prevailing in society is
not a real issue for them.
Such authorities warn anyone criticizing their policies that
the criticism should be carried out "within the corridor of law
or else they will face the strong arm of law." This legalistic
attitude has barely changed since the fall of Soeharto's New
Order.
If our legal system values legality more than the principle of
justice, can our legal system be confidently claimed as a system
that really strives towards achieving the rule of law?
There are three classical requirements which any legal system
must fulfill above all others so that it can even claim to be
considered as constituting the rule of law. They are that laws
must be general, equal and certain.
Law must be general. It means law has to provide the same
treatment to all people. When the law says one has to go to jail
for an offense he has committed, the judges are under their
inherent obligation attached to their profession to be faithful
in implementing what the law has declared despite the fact that
no written provision literally inhibits them from acting
otherwise.
Thus the judges must order each convicted criminal to
immediately serve his/her prison time for the offense(s) they
commit, irrespective of their social status or their political
connections.
Our constitution also guarantees that every citizen is equal
before the law. What judges ought to examine is what has been
done and to what extent such a crime has damaged society, not
only who is guilty of the crime.
The differences in opportunities for "those who know nobody"
and "those who know everyone" is a reality outside the court.
However, the court must recognize that social differences do
indeed exist, such differences must not cloud the judgment in
delivering justice. Such differences must not be used as a
rationale behind court rulings to benefit particular people.
Finally, the law must be consistent. When the court hands down
a verdict and a sentence to one person, it has to do the same to
others so society will get the right message that the law is
consistent. Court rulings that stop short in completing the
proper administration of justice set a "biased" precedent for the
campaign against the rule of law.
When law is created based more on circumstance or situation
rather than principle, then uncertainty and inconsistency will
reign, and this encourages corruption. We are clearly far from
moving closer to the rule of law -- instead we are becoming much
closer to the law of the few, as we were under the former regime.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/jp6andi-1447899208-1367702)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post