Corruption threatens Indonesia's defense system
Corruption threatens Indonesia's defense system
Munir
Executive Director
Indonesian Human Rights Monitor
Jakarta
The House of Representatives announced on Tuesday it has planned
to set up a working committee of inquiry into alleged
irregularities in the Military's procurement of Mi-17 helicopters
from Russia. The case emerged following a report on the
disappearance of US$3.2 million as a down payment to Russia for
the purchase of four Mi-17 helicopters for the Army.
Members of Commission I said they had received reports the
helicopters should have been valued at only $17.6 million, a
price 25 percent lower than the $21.6 million the Army had agreed
to pay. The helicopters were due at the end of February but as
Tempo magazine reported, a Russian firm stopped assembling the
them as it had not received the down payment of $3.2 million.
On Wednesday, the Commission met with Military chief Gen.
Endriartono Sutarto who rebuked the defense ministry for its
"criminal" act of buying the Mi17s.
Shopping for military equipment has become a major past-time
in military circles -- while the civilian political authorities'
control over the defense system seems to be getting weaker.
The incident above appears to illustrate the wastage brought
on by an abuse of power. Meanwhile, the Indonesian Military
(TNI) continues to complain about its lack of equipment and low
military budget. It is worthwhile if we examine the case more
thoroughly.
The government, represented by President Megawati
Soekarnoputri and Endriartono bought four Sukhoi jet fighters
from Russia last year. Through an export credit exchange system,
the purchase was to be paid for in several years of installments.
It was, however, conducted without the DPR's approval.
The Minister of Defense, Matori Abdul Djalil, even went so far
as to deny all knowledge of the aircraft purchase plan in August.
The DPR also questioned the deal for not being included in last
year's draft budget.
Suspicion of a dodgy markup and other corruption behind the
Sukhoi purchase became a subject of hot debate in the House. But
then there were indications of a political compromise -- this
year's defense budget was drawn up to legitimize the aircraft
purchase. Too little, too late, it failed to reflect any
awareness of the importance of a transparent and accountable
policy on the procurement of military equipment.
Then, following the introduction of regional autonomy, several
regional administrations and the TNI initiated the purchase of
patrol boats through regional funding. Seven provinces allocated
$1.5 million (Rp 13 billion) each to buy KAL-35 vessels from a
business partner of the Navy. Papua allotted no less than $9
million to buy naval boats from a European country. This means
the imposition of operational costs by the TNI on the routine
budget of the regions.
This issue could have been avoided if the government, the DPR
and the TNI had observed Law No.3/2002 on state defense -- which
says that the budget for state defense is to be derived only from
central government, while regional administrations have no
authority to allocate funds for this purpose.
In this case, despite the statement of a defense ministry
official that regional purchases were illegal, the ministry, the
Navy and regional administrations proceeded with the plan. The
purchase of the vessels was even contained in memorandums of
understanding (MOU) between the regions concerned and the Navy,
in which the latter served as a party with the authority to act
in the interests of state defense. Further, the Navy acted like
it was an organization selling security services to the regions.
In mid-January, the Navy Chief of Staff, Vice Adm. Bernard
Kent Sondakh, signed the purchase of two Corvette ships from the
Netherlands. Again, the transaction was conducted by the Navy on
behalf of the defense ministry. The purchase was carried out amid
procedural irregularities and questionable government financing.
The Corvette procurement plan followed the Navy chief's visit
to the Netherlands mid last year. The Navy requested the
government allocate funds for four Corvettes. But until a few
days before the signing of an MOU, the government announced that
the available funds were inadequate.
Last month, Minister of Finance Budiono asked the Navy to
revise the purchase deal of two Corvettes but Bernard strongly
objected. Suspicions brewed the Navy had managed to present the
civilian political authorities with a fait accompli.
These developments reflect the fundamental weakness of the
President and the DPR as civilian political authorities to manage
the diverse aspects of defense and military affairs.
This weakness concerns all stages, from planning, purchase and
use -- a lack of control over the entire process. Worse, there is
no national legal system existing to fund the regional needs of
the TNI.
The defense budget for the fiscal year of 2004, worth Rp 13.2
trillion, fails to reflect the nation's defense policy. Military
funds are now mainly derived from regional administrations and
reserve funds are used in the name of military operations or
unplanned equipment purchases.
The problem is no longer only the loss of civilian control
over the military through the budget policy, but also the high
likelihood of collusion and corruption in the purchase of
military equipment.
The absence of a system to support the budget policy paves the
way to a chaotic public administration. There will likely be more
irregularities in the purchase of military equipment related to
the TNI's internal power struggles, and the return of the
involvement of civilian politicians, who will fight over the
spoils of corrupt purchases.
These developments are intolerable. The military budget system
should be restructured and civilian political authorities should
take over all armament purchases from the military. There should
also be the consistent policing of any military involvement in
politics.
Without significant reforms, Indonesia's military and
political authorities will face bankruptcy before long.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/jp3munir-1447899208-1474724)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post