JP/1/REVISION

.RM 11.00"

Law No. 3/2002 on national defense ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Original articles Proposed articles ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Article 11: Article 11: As the defense instrument, the TNI's (1). TNI is an organization which organization structure, roles and is directly under the ministry duties are being regulated by the law. of defense.

(2). As the defense insrument, TNI's

organization structure, roles

and duties are being regulated

by the law.

Article 22: Article 22: (4). In a direct deployment of the TNI (4). In a direct deployment of TNI

force, the president should ask force, the president must secure

for an approval from lawmakers a written approval from lawmakers

within 2x24 hours after the deployment within 2x24 hours after the deployment.

Article 17: Article 17: The president appoints and dismisses The president appoints and dismisses TNI chief after wins an approval from TNI chief. lawmakers. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Law No. 34/2004 on the military --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Original articles Proposed articles ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Article 12:

(an additional point)

(4). TNI is under the Ministry of Defense's

organization structure.

Article 13 Article 13:

(an additional point)

(2). The TNI chief is a subordinate to

defense minister. (2) TNI chief is being instaled and (3). TNI chief is being installed and

dismissed by the president, who must dismissed by the president.

wins an approval from lawmakers.

Article 14 Article 14 (1). All chiefs of staffs are being (1). All chiefs of staffs are being appointed

appointed and dismissed by the and dismissed by the president upon

president based on a recommendation hearing the TNI chief's considerations.

of the TNI chief

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Law No 2/2002 on National Police ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Original article Proposed articles ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Article 8: Article 8: (1) The National Police is under (1) The National Police is under

the president. ministry of home affairs. (2) National Police chief is responsibles (2) National Police chief is responsibles

directly to the president directly to minister of home affairs.

Article 9 Article 9 (1) National Police chief defines, (1) Minister of home affairs defines a general

implements and manages the technicall policy on the national police, and manages

policy on the national police. and supervises the implementation of the

policy.

Article 10 Article 10 (1) Heads of regional police are (1) Heads of regional police are responsible

responsible to their superiors based on to the minister and head of regional

hierarchic line. based on hierarchic line.

Article 11 Article 11 (1) National Police chief is being (1) National Police chief is being

appointed and dismissed by the president appointed and dismissed by the president

after the later wins an approval upon hearing considerations from lawmakers

from lawmakers.

(7) Under a certain circumstances, national (7) Under a certain circumstances, national

police chief can be dismissed by the police chief can be dismissed by the

president, who appoints an ex-officio president, who appoints an ex-officio

to be in charge and later on asks for to be in charge and later on asks for

an approval from lawmakers a consideration from lawmakers

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------