Journalist Organisations Unite to Condemn Hotman Paris for Disparaging Remarks
Several journalist professional organisations in Indonesia have jointly issued strong condemnation of lawyer Hotman Paris Hutapea, judging him arrogant and demeaning towards the dignity of journalists during a press conference at the Attorney General’s Office (Kejagung) building on Friday (17/7).
Those condemning Hotman include the Editors’ Forum (Forum Pemred), the Indonesian Television Journalists Association (IJTI), the Central Board of the Indonesian Journalists Association (PWI), and the Legal Journalists Association (Iwakum).
The incident began when Hotman was speaking on behalf of his client, former Head of the Attorney General’s Office’s Special Crimes Investigation Febrie Adriansyah, who is now a suspect in a corruption case.
Rather than responding professionally, Hotman answered journalists’ questions with remarks deemed insulting and intimidating.
He uttered phrases such as “do you have a brain?”, told journalists to “shut up” and ask their grandfathers, and labelled journalists “cowards” for not daring to pose questions at the National Police Headquarters.
The Chair of the Editors’ Forum, Retno Pinasti, expressed regret over Hotman’s choice of words and manner, considered highly improper and failing to address the substance of the questions.
Retno reminded that asking questions and verifying data are journalists’ rights and professional discipline protected under Press Law Number 40 of 1999.
“It is highly improper for a source to respond to journalists’ questions in a demeaning way, whether through word choice such as ‘do you have a brain’, or through an arrogant attitude that completely fails to answer the substance of the question,” Retno said in a written statement on Sunday (19/7).
Echoing this, IJTI Chairman Herik Kurniawan affirmed that critical questions from journalists are not attempts to stir up trouble, but rather part of professional duty to produce balanced news (cover both sides).
Herik highlighted that Hotman’s verbal actions violated the values of professionalism and Articles 1 and 3 of the Journalistic Code of Ethics.
“IJTI reminds everyone of the importance of mutual respect and maintaining ethical communication between professions. Issuing statements that demean another profession is tantamount to violating those very professional values,” he said.
Calls for an apology and an ethics hearing
As a consequence of this verbal arrogance, PWI Central Board and Iwakum have officially urged Hotman Paris to deliver an open apology to members of the press.
PWI Chairman Akhmad Munir stated that an advocate does indeed have the right to refuse to answer questions in defence of a client, but that right must not be used to intimidate another profession.
“Criticising journalists’ questions is perfectly normal, but it must be conveyed courteously, professionally, and without demeaning the dignity of the press,” Akhmad said, as quoted by detikcom on Sunday (19/7).
A tougher demand came from Iwakum. Iwakum Chairman Irfan Kamil said Hotman’s statements were not mere criticism, but a direct attack on journalists’ intellectual capacity.
Therefore, Iwakum requested that the advocates’ organisation to which Hotman belongs also step in to examine alleged violations of the code of ethics relating to his behaviour in the public sphere.
“The statement ‘do you have a brain?’ is not criticism, it is an insult to journalists,” Kamil said.
The four organisations agreed that advocates and journalists are two professions that each play a strategic role in upholding the law. Accordingly, mutual respect must be prioritised to safeguard a healthy democratic climate.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/journalist-organisations-unite-to-condemn-hotman-paris-for-disparaging-remarks-1784528412)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260720093305-20-1382605/ramai-ramai-kecam-hotman-paris-rendahkan-martabat-wartawan), translated from Indonesian