Jobs Dominated by Women Paid Less Despite Equal Skills, Study Confirms
Gender-based pay inequality remains a thorny issue in the global world of work. A recent study published in the journal Research in Social Stratification and Mobility confirms that types of work dominated by women tend to be valued less and paid less than those dominated by men, even when levels of skill and education are equivalent.
This phenomenon aligns with the “devaluation hypothesis” advanced by Paula England of New York University Abu Dhabi since the mid-1990s. The theory holds that work associated with women is often regarded as culturally less valuable, which has a direct impact on lower wage setting.
To test the theory in depth, Professor Catherine Taylor of the University of California, Santa Barbara (UCSB), together with a research team from four universities, conducted a controlled experiment on a representative sample of thousands of adults.
“The theory says that we devalue women’s contributions in society,” Taylor said.
“Women still earn 85 cents for every one dollar earned by men, and we know part of the reason is that women are in lower-paid professions. But our research asked: do we really pay a profession less because there are women in it?”
In the experiment, the researchers used one gender-neutral job description — a management consultant. All descriptions of tasks, skills and work demands were made identical. The only thing varied was the proportion of women in the field: 25 per cent (male-dominated), 45 per cent, and 67 per cent (female-dominated).
Respondents were then asked to suggest a starting base salary for a new university graduate, within a range of US$40,000 to US$100,000 per year.
The results showed that the female-dominated version of the job (67 per cent) received a significantly lower recommended starting salary than the male-dominated version, with a gap of around US$865 per year. This reduction was agreed upon by both male and female respondents. Moreover, the pay bias only emerged when the profession was clearly portrayed as majority female.
Interestingly, the bias did not stem from the view that female workers were less skilled or less committed, since assessments of workers’ abilities remained the same. In other words, devaluation occurs in the profession itself.
“I think it’s important for employers to understand that they themselves sometimes devalue women without thinking about it,” Taylor said. “The pay gap is not about women having an inherent preference for jobs that offer lower wages, but rather that we pay women’s professions less because we devalue women.”
As a remedial step, Taylor suggested that companies apply objective pay standards.
“One suggestion is for employers to make sure their pay criteria are standardised, for example based on a certain level of education and the number of years of an employee’s experience, regardless of gender,” Taylor said. “For employers, making the effort to create this equality is well worth it. It is better for the organisation when there is greater equality.”
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/jobs-dominated-by-women-paid-less-despite-equal-skills-study-confirms-1784616677)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/humaniora/912907/mengapa-pekerjaan-dominasi-perempuan-digaji-lebih-murah-ini-temuan-studi-terbaru), translated from Indonesian