Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Jimly Says Gibran’s Resignation Must Not Be Like Soeharto’s and Must Be Subject to Proof

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Jimly Says Gibran’s Resignation Must Not Be Like Soeharto’s and Must Be Subject to Proof
Image: Republika

JAKARTA — Constitutional law expert Prof Jimly Asshiddiqie believes that Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s resignation or impeachment from the vice-presidency must follow a procedure. Jimly does not want Gibran simply to resign without going through a process of establishing the facts.

Jimly said there is no procedure for the resignation of an Indonesian vice-president. Resignation is addressed in Article 3 of the 1945 Constitution, which differs from the provisions on impeachment.

Historically, a resignation took place during Soeharto’s era. At the time, Soeharto had not been directly elected by the people as president; he was elected by the MPR. Jimly therefore said Gibran could not announce his resignation in the same way as Soeharto.

“The issue now is that the president and vice-president are elected directly by the people. It was different back then, in Mr Harto’s era. Back then, they were elected by the MPR. So President Soeharto simply resigned, right? He sent [a letter]. The problem with Mr Harto’s case was that he spoke on his own at the Palace. The MPR leadership was not even there,” Jimly told Republika on Tuesday (10 November 2026).

Jimly stressed that a vice-president elected directly by the people should not be able to resign just like that. He said the resignation should follow a procedure.

“The procedure for resignation has indeed not yet been regulated. But with the change to a system of direct presidential elections, a president or vice-president elected by 58 per cent of the Indonesian people cannot simply say on their own that they want to resign. There has to be a mechanism,” Jimly said.

Jimly also said he believed there was not yet a detailed mechanism for the resignation of an Indonesian vice-president. He questioned whether the office would become vacant immediately upon the vice-president’s resignation.

“First, should he send an official resignation letter to the president and the MPR? That is one question; there is no regulation on it yet. Second, if he declares that he is resigning, does that mean the office is immediately vacant?” Jimly said.

Jimly proposed that the vice-president submit a resignation to the President and the MPR. This would allow the President and the MPR to prepare for the vice-president’s departure under the constitutional system.

“Say he decides that his resignation will take effect from the first of the month — for example, ‘I, the vice-president, resign on 1 December’. Then the vacancy would begin on the first. If the office becomes vacant, the MPR will convene. The President will put forward two candidates for the MPR to elect,” Jimly said.

More from 11 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/jimly-says-gibrans-resignation-must-not-be-like-soehartos-and-must-be-subject-to-proof-1794351034)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/toalil487/jimly-sebut-pengunduran-diri-gibran-tidak-boleh-seperti-soeharto-tetap-harus-disertai-pembuktian), translated from Indonesian
Print