Jimly Says Gibran’s Challenge at the Administrative Court Will Be Difficult, Citing His Reasons
JAKARTA — Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s decision to continue pursuing the diploma controversy at the State Administrative Court (PTUN) should be respected. However, constitutional law expert Prof Jimly Asshiddiqie is pessimistic that the effort will produce results.
Jimly said rulings by the Supreme Court (MA) and the Constitutional Court (MK) could already serve as a reference for Gibran’s position. The former chief justice of the Constitutional Court questioned what more there was to pursue at the PTUN.
“But, practically speaking, there has already been a Supreme Court ruling. It is the highest [court]. What else is there to pursue legally? There have already been rulings from the Supreme Court. Both the MK and MA rulings are strong. It just needs to be processed in the DPR, then it goes to the MK, and then to the MPR,” Jimly told Republika on Tuesday (10 November 2026).
Jimly suggested that President Prabowo had allowed Gibran to pursue legal action as an example of good governmental conduct. “Yes, it was based on the President’s suggestion that he should fight. In reality, it won’t be of any benefit. But from the President’s perspective, it is a good thing. The President is not simply accepting it. After all, the presidential candidate himself asked him [Gibran] to run as vice-president. So, in terms of proper conduct, I think what President Prabowo meant was a healthy fight. That’s good. But it is up to Mr Gibran,” Jimly said.
Jimly believes Gibran is capable of assembling his own legal team, although he expects the PTUN challenge to face difficulties following the MA and MK rulings.
“Will he keep fighting? That’s fine. His campaign team and legal team are substantial. He can try first. Although, generally speaking, I can say it will be rather difficult because there has already been a Supreme Court ruling. But there is nothing wrong with making the attempt,” Jimly said.
Resignation procedure
Jimly said Gibran’s resignation from the vice-presidency would need to follow a procedure. He does not want Gibran simply to step down without a process to establish the circumstances.
Jimly said there is no specific resignation procedure for an Indonesian vice-president. Resignation is addressed in Article 3 of the 1945 Constitution, which differs from the provisions on impeachment.
Historically, resignation occurred during Soeharto’s era. At the time, Soeharto had not been directly elected by the public but by the MPR. Jimly therefore said Gibran could not simply announce his resignation in the same way as Soeharto.
“The issue now is that the president and vice-president are elected directly by the people. It was different back then, in Mr Soeharto’s time, when they were elected by the MPR. So President Soeharto simply resigned, right? He sent [a letter]. The problem with Mr Soeharto was that he spoke by himself at the Palace. The MPR leadership was not even present,” Jimly told Republika on Tuesday (10 November 2026).
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/jimly-says-gibrans-challenge-at-the-administrative-court-will-be-difficult-citing-his-reasons-1794369096)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/tobgou487/jimly-yakin-perlawanan-gibran-di-ptun-akan-sulit-ini-argumennya), translated from Indonesian