Japanese National Challenges Civil Code at Constitutional Court Over Rp291 Billion Inheritance Dispute
A Japanese national, Hisako Dewanto, has submitted a petition to the Constitutional Court (MK) to conduct a judicial review of the provisions in Article 140 of the Indonesian Civil Code (KUHPer/Burgerlijk Wetboek voor Indonesie). The petition is registered under number 334/PUU-XXIV/2026.
During a hearing regarding the revision of the petition on Monday (28/9), legal counsel Fatiatulo Lazira explained that due to the ambiguity of the norms in Article 140 of the Civil Code, Hisako has lost her inheritance rights as the surviving spouse. Consequently, her client has also lost the right to access and trace the inherited assets of her late husband.
“Based on documents from the tax office, there are assets under the name of Hisako Dewanto’s late husband that have not been reported, totalling up to Rp231 billion, including assets worth approximately Rp60 billion abroad,” Fati stated on Tuesday (29/6).
Fati added that there are several bank accounts in the personal name of the late Rachmat Hartojo (Hisako’s husband) being used by other parties, with indications that they are being used to manipulate financial transactions. According to information obtained, the late Rachmat Hartojo had previously purchased 43 kilograms of gold in stages using cash payments.
Regarding the aforementioned gold, information from the late Rachmat Hartojo during his lifetime indicated it was handed over to his mother. Furthermore, there are strong indications that the funds used to purchase the gold were withdrawn in cash from companies in which the late Rachmat Hartojo held shares.
In addition, Fati stated that her client has also lost the right to inherit the deceased’s shares. “Hisako has also lost the right to inherit the late Rachmat Hartojo’s shares in several companies, including PT Megamarine Pride, PT Baramuda Bahari, and PT Mega Marine Prime,” said Fati.
There are four petitioners challenging the judicial review of Article 140 of the Civil Code at the Constitutional Court. Alongside Hisako, the petitioners include a married couple, Hartono Effendi (Petitioner III) and Chientasari Ichsan (Petitioner IV), as well as an Indonesian student, Jessica Tritanya (Petitioner II).
The petitioners are contesting the provisions of Article 140 of the Civil Code because they limit the scope of marriage agreements, frequently resulting in the surviving spouse losing their inheritance rights.
According to the petitioners, even though Hisako is a foreign national, the provisions of Article 140 of the Civil Code should remain binding on everyone within the jurisdiction of Indonesian law. Fati also revealed that Hisako holds an Indonesian ID (KTP) and has been a permanent resident of Surabaya since marrying Indonesian national Rachmat Hartojo in 1997, with whom she had three children.
According to the Constitutional Court website, after her husband passed away, the eldest child, in their capacity as a child and/or heir, issued a statement in November 2022 granting Hisako the authority to manage the late father’s estate. The second child also provided authority to manage the inheritance certificate. The third child, being a minor at the time, was legally represented by Hisako as a guardian.
However, the eldest child issued a revocation of that authority in December of the same year. Since then, Fati stated that inheritance disputes have emerged between Hisako and the children, as well as between her client and her late husband’s mother.
The eldest child filed a lawsuit which was partially granted, with a ruling that essentially divided the entire estate into one-third shares for each heir, excluding Hisako.
This decision was upheld at the cassation level, which considered the existence of a derivative marriage agreement deed, making the marriage agreement binding on the parties involved. This means that upon the death of one party, separate property or pre-marital assets remain the property of each individual as there is no joint property, and inheritance is divided according to the terms of the marriage agreement.
Consequently, Hisako has no right to inherit her late husband’s estate, and vice versa.
For reference, the current Article 140 of the Civil Code states that marriage agreements must not reduce rights derived from the husband’s authority or the rights given by law to the surviving spouse. It also stipulates that agreements cannot reduce the wife’s right to manage her personal assets or enjoy her personal income.
The petitioners argue that this norm contradicts Articles 1 paragraph (3), 28D paragraph (1), and 28H paragraph (4) of the 1945 Constitution. Therefore, in their petition, they request the Constitutional Court to declare the phrase “nor rights which are given by law to the one who lives longest” in Article 140 of the Civil Code as conditionally unconstitutional, provided it is interpreted to mean that marriage agreements, including total separation of assets, cannot abolish or reduce the position and share of the surviving spouse as an heir, including for foreign nationals, while remaining subject to land-related regulations.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/japanese-national-challenges-civil-code-at-constitutional-court-over-rp291-billion-inheritance-dispute-1790657983)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260929104614-12-1409381/wn-jepang-gugat-kuhperdata-ke-mk-terkait-harta-almarhum-suami-rp291-m), translated from Indonesian