Jansen Responds to Supreme Court Ruling: Gibran Must Resign as Vice-President or Be Removed
Democratic Party deputy secretary-general Jansen Sitindaon believes Gibran Rakabuming Raka no longer meets the requirements to serve as Vice-President following a Supreme Court ruling concerning his high-school diploma equivalency certificate. Jansen says Gibran now has only two options regarding the office.
Jansen initially examined a Constitutional Court ruling on a challenge to the 2024 election results concerning Gibran’s high-school diploma. He said the ruling was inconclusive because it stated that the diploma had not been found or could not be found. In his view, the Supreme Court’s more recent ruling was different.
“Unlike the Supreme Court ruling, whose order is very firm, explicit and clear, and needs no further interpretation, it states: ‘invalid, null and void by law, to be withdrawn from whoever holds it and destroyed’,” Jansen wrote on his social media account on Sunday (1 November 2026).
Given that the Supreme Court declared the certificate invalid and null and void by law, and ordered its destruction, Jansen considers Gibran’s legitimacy as Vice-President to be in question. His argument is based on Article 7A of the 1945 Constitution.
“If we follow the wording of the Supreme Court’s order literally, as the legal basis, then Mr Gibran’s status is no longer valid and is null and void by law as Vice-President, in line with the status of the certificate he used, which the Supreme Court has now even ordered to be destroyed,” he said.
On that basis, Jansen said Gibran had only two choices concerning the vice-presidency: resign or be removed or impeached by the People’s Consultative Assembly and the House of Representatives.
“Since he is no longer valid and eligible to serve as Vice-President, in my view there are now only two options: Mr Gibran resigns from the vice-presidency with dignity, or the House of Representatives, acting through the People’s Consultative Assembly, ‘removes’ him by invoking Article 7A of the 1945 Constitution,” Jansen said.
Jansen said the Supreme Court ruling concerning Gibran’s status differs from criminal cases, which are enforced by prosecutors, and civil cases, whose enforcement is carried out by bailiffs. Because this case concerns a state office, he said, the People’s Consultative Assembly and the House of Representatives would have to enforce it if Gibran did not resign.
“Otherwise, this ruling will remain nothing more than words on paper,” he said.
Jansen also discussed the possibility of the Constitutional Court and Supreme Court rulings leading to political enforcement by the two legislative bodies. He said that decision rested with senior political figures and party elites.
“This is now a matter for the ‘gods’, whose station is in the heavens. Those of us at ground level can only offer legal opinions,” he added.
Gibran’s lawyer responds to the Supreme Court ruling
Gibran’s lawyer, Muhammad Rullyandi, offered a different view, saying the Supreme Court ruling would not affect his client’s position as Vice-President. He argued that the ruling could not be fully enforced because the legal circumstances had changed before it was issued.
“I consider that the Supreme Court ruling granting the request to annul the validity of Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s high-school education equivalency certificate, which was an administrative requirement for his nomination as Vice-President in the 2024 election, does not affect Gibran’s position as Vice-President,” Rullyandi told reporters on Saturday (31 October).
“The reason is that the Supreme Court ruling cannot be fully enforced because of the legal circumstances that had already arisen,” he added.
Rullyandi explained that the Supreme Court issued its ruling after all stages of the 2024 presidential election had concluded and Gibran had been formally sworn in as Vice-President. He therefore argued that the ruling could not be applied retroactively.
“The Supreme Court ruling meets the criteria in the context of administrative court proceedings, with reference to Article 117(1) of Law No. 5 of 1986, which essentially states that an imperfect ruling cannot be enforced because the legal circumstances have already changed,” he said.
Rullyandi said the equivalency certificate had been used to meet the administrative requirements for nomination during the 2024 election, which has now concluded. Although the Supreme Court ruling is legally binding, he said, it cannot be used to remove Gibran.
“Although the Supreme Court ruling is legally binding, it cannot be fully enforced; it is non-executable and cannot be used as a basis for the House of Representatives’ political action to impeach him,” he said.
He added that the Supreme Court ruling could still be challenged through an extraordinary legal review, which the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education could pursue as the defendant.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/jansen-responds-to-supreme-court-ruling-gibran-must-resign-as-vice-president-or-be-removed-1793505088)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8733208/jansen-pd-respons-putusan-ma-gibran-mundur-dari-wapres-atau-dimundurkan), translated from Indonesian