Jakarta Information Commission Socialises Public Information Dispute Resolution for Elections
The Jakarta Information Commission (KI) has socialised the resolution of public information disputes during general elections to the ranks of the General Elections Commission (KPU) through an ‘In-House Training Workshop’ on techniques and strategies for legal proceedings.
“Because it relates to the General Election, we have a specific regulation, namely Perki Number 1 of 2019, which regulates the service standards and procedures for resolving information disputes in elections. These provisions apply during the stages of the general election and local elections,” said the Chairman of the Jakarta Provincial Information Commission, Harry Ara Hutabarat, in Jakarta on Friday.
Harry explained that the resolution of public information disputes at the Information Commission is guided by Information Commission Regulation (Perki) Number 1 of 2013 regarding the Procedures for Resolving Public Information Disputes. Meanwhile, disputes regarding election stages are subject to specific provisions regulated under Perki Number 1 of 2019.
In the process of resolving public information disputes, the opposing parties at the Information Commission are the information applicant and the public body as the respondent. Applicants can fall into three categories: individuals (who must attach identification such as a National ID card), groups or class actions (which must include the identity of the proxy and group representative), and legal entities (which must attach the deed of establishment and organisational legality documents).
“The trial process begins with the examination of legal standing. All parties must complete their legal standing documents as a requirement to participate in the dispute resolution process at the Information Commission,” he said.
Once the legal standing of the parties is deemed valid, the board of commissioners will examine the status of the requested information, including verifying whether the information is under the control of the public body and whether it is classified as open or exempted.
If the requested information is deemed open, the Information Commission will encourage the parties to first undergo a mediation process. “We will encourage the parties to resolve disputes through mediation facilitated by the Information Commission’s mediator. We hope disputes can be fully resolved through the mediation route,” he added.
If the requested information is classified as exempt, or if mediation fails to reach an agreement, the dispute will proceed to the adjudication stage through evidentiary hearings. Harry emphasised that the designation of information as ‘exempt’ must be conducted through a consequence test mechanism by the public body. The results of this test must be documented in a decision letter signed by the head of the Information and Documentation Management Officer (PPID).
“The exemption of public information is the authority of the public body. Therefore, the KPU must carefully examine the information under its control to determine which is open and which is exempt according to statutory regulations,” he emphasised. During evidentiary hearings, parties may present various forms of evidence, including written documents, witnesses, and experts, to strengthen their respective arguments.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/jakarta-information-commission-socialises-public-information-dispute-resolution-for-elections-1785488435)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5674188/ki-jakarta-sosialisasi-penyelesaian-sengketa-informasi-publik-pemilu), translated from Indonesian