Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Jakarta Administrative Court Dismisses Gibran’s High School Certificate Equivalency Case

| Source: CNN Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Jakarta Administrative Court Dismisses Gibran’s High School Certificate Equivalency Case
Image: CNN Indonesia

The Jakarta Administrative Court (PTUN) has declared moot a lawsuit filed by Mercy Toga Kirana concerning the high school education equivalency certificate issued for Gibran Rakabuming Raka.

The court said the object of the lawsuit—the equivalency certificate for Gibran—had been withdrawn or revoked by the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education.

“Hereby rules: first, the plaintiff’s lawsuit is declared moot. Second, the plaintiff is ordered to pay court costs of 457,000 rupiah,” presiding judge Rahmadi said during a follow-up hearing at the Jakarta Administrative Court on Thursday (12 November).

The ruling followed consideration of several matters by the judges. The first was the disputed document: a letter issued by the Director-General of Primary and Secondary Education at the Ministry of Education and Culture, numbered 9149/D.D1/KS/2019 and dated 6 August 2019.

The court said it had received on Thursday (12 November) a decree from the Director-General of Secondary and Special Education at the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education, Number 206 of 2026, revoking that letter. The revocation itself was reportedly made on 11 November 2026.

Following the revocation, the defendant, the Director-General of Special Education at the ministry, asked the panel to halt and discontinue its examination of the dispute.

“Having considered the defendant’s request, the plaintiff essentially stated that it had no objection,” Rahmadi said.

The panel also took into account an objection to ending the case submitted by the intervening defendant, Gibran Rakabuming Raka.

The judges considered that, in implementing the Supreme Court’s cassation ruling, the ministry had revoked the decision at the heart of the dispute, rendering it no longer valid and without legal force.

“[However,] the panel has found no provision that clearly governs the discontinuation of proceedings when the disputed decision has been annulled or revoked in implementation of a court ruling with permanent legal force,” Rahmadi said.

The panel therefore drew on a similar legal concept applied in other areas of public law, particularly criminal law. Rahmadi also said that if the examination continued, the judgment in the dispute would be non-executable.

The judges also cited the need to safeguard the democratic climate and bring an end to prolonged controversy. The presiding judge said no further legal challenge could be brought in the case.

“Accordingly, this ruling declaring the case moot leaves no further opportunity for examination or evidentiary proceedings, and no legal remedy may be filed,” Rahmadi said as he read the panel’s reasoning.

The plaintiff in the lawsuit was PT Mercy Toga Kirana, while the defendant was the Director-General of Secondary and Special Education at the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education.

The plaintiff asked the court to declare invalid or unlawful Decree No. 9149/D.D1/KS/2019, dated 6 August 2019, concerning the equivalency of Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s certificate.

More from 12 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/jakarta-administrative-court-dismisses-gibrans-high-school-certificate-equivalency-case-1794480779)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261112163358-12-1426488/hakim-ptun-putuskan-gugatan-suket-ijazah-sma-gibran-gugur), translated from Indonesian
Print