ISEAI: Military Involvement in Tax Oversight Risks Intimidating Taxpayers
The Indonesia Strategic and Economic Action Institution (ISEAI) has assessed that the involvement of Babinsa (village non-commissioned officers) and Bhabinkamtibmas (community security and order supervisors) in monitoring taxpayer compliance carries the potential to create fear or discomfort among taxpayers.
According to ISEAI Senior Analyst Ronny P. Sasmita, public perception of the presence of security personnel can influence how people respond to tax policy. This is because members of the Indonesian National Armed Forces (TNI) and National Police occupy strong positions within the social structure of society. Consequently, their presence, even when not carrying out tax audits or law enforcement, can still have a psychological effect on taxpayers, especially small business owners and ordinary members of the public.
“Formally, they are indeed not conducting audits or law enforcement,” Ronny told Tempo on Tuesday evening, 21 July 2026. However, he said that for small business owners or ordinary citizens, the situation may feel like being visited by the state at full force. That is dangerous because healthy tax compliance should be built on trust, not on implicit pressure.
Ronny said the government needs to prepare clear guardrails if it wishes to ensure the policy is not perceived as a form of pressure on taxpayers. The role of Babinsa and Bhabinkamtibmas must be limited to administrative support only, with no direct interaction with taxpayers in a tax context.
In addition, he believes the Directorate General of Taxes (DJP) needs to strengthen public communication by openly explaining that the presence of these officers is purely for administrative support, and does not form part of tax monitoring or law enforcement.
Ronny also encouraged the DJP to provide an easily accessible complaints mechanism for members of the public who feel intimidated during the implementation of the policy. The risk of misuse of the officers’ presence could still arise not because of the policy’s objective, but as a result of dynamics in its implementation on the ground.
He further proposed that the government carry out periodic evaluations, the results of which should be made public. This step, he said, is necessary to ensure the policy runs accountably.
Ronny assessed that the main challenge of the policy lies not in the government’s formal explanations, but in the potential emergence of a trust deficit within society. In tax policy, public perception is as important as the substance of the policy, because public discomfort can render a technically sound policy counterproductive.
Director General of Taxes Bimo Wijayanto emphasised that the involvement of Babinsa and Bhabinkamtibmas is not intended to carry out the functions of tax inspectors or tax collectors, but merely to support coordination in information gathering.
“So village officials and the like coordinate with us; they are not to be portrayed as carrying out tax audits or tax collection, not at all,” Bimo said at the APBN KiTa press conference for July 2026, quoted by Antara.
The issue surrounding the involvement of Babinsa and Bhabinkamtibmas surfaced after the Directorate General of Taxes issued Circular Letter Number SE-8/PJ/2026 concerning Guidelines for Monitoring Taxpayer Compliance.
He explained that the presence of territorial officers is not the primary instrument for monitoring taxpayer compliance. The DJP currently relies more heavily on the use of technology, such as Coretax and geotagging-based monitoring.
“So their presence there supports joint coordination, and even then it is not the main ‘weapon’. The main weapons are far more advanced: we use our compliance risk management (CRM) engine, we use our geotagging surveillance, we use our Coretax. If clarification is genuinely needed, there are territorial supervisors at the regional level,” he said.
Bimo stated that the mechanism is not a new policy, as it has been regulated since 2020. The latest circular letter merely refines its implementation procedures.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/iseai-military-involvement-in-tax-oversight-risks-intimidating-taxpayers-1784778938)
Originally published by Tempo Bisnis (https://bisnis.tempo.co/read/2115024/iseai-pelibatan-tentara-berpotensi-menakutkan-wajib-pajak), translated from Indonesian