Is the Viral Intimate-Shaped Croissant Halal? Check This MUI Fatwa for Guidance
The virality of a croissant in Thailand with an appearance resembling intimate organs or pubic hair has sparked discussion on social media. So, is the pastry halal?
The Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI) Fatwa Number 44 of 2020 stipulates that products using erotic and pornographic forms or packaging cannot be halal certified.
The pastry trend, known as Croissant Pattaya, first went viral in Thailand before spreading across various social media platforms. The croissant became viral not because of its taste, but because its appearance was deemed to resemble pubic hair, eliciting various reactions from netizens.
In Fatwa MUI Number 44 of 2020 concerning the ‘Use of Product Names, Forms and Packaging That Cannot Be Halal Certified’, the MUI Fatwa Commission has established several categories of products that cannot obtain halal certification. One of these is products using packaging or forms containing erotic and pornographic elements.
In the Legal Provisions section, the fatwa states that products which cannot be halal certified include, among others, products using names or symbols with negative connotations, products shaped like pigs and dogs, products with packaging featuring images of pigs and dogs as the main focus, and products using flavours or aromas of forbidden substances. ‘Products using packaging shaped and/or depicting erotic and pornographic content (cannot be halal certified),’ as quoted from the MUI Fatwa.
In its considerations, the MUI explains that the concept of thayyib does not only relate to the content of halal and good ingredients, but also encompasses the name, form, and packaging of the product. The fatwa cites a hadith of the Prophet Muhammad SAW, narrated by Abu Hurairah RA, stating that Allah is thayyib (good) and does not accept anything except that which is thayyib (good and halal) (HR Muslim).
The MUI also bases the fatwa on several principles of Islamic jurisprudence, including the principle that preventing harm takes precedence over achieving benefit (dar’ul mafasid muqaddam ’ala jalbil mashalih) and that harm must be eliminated.
Through its recommendations, the MUI urges scholars to disseminate this fatwa to the public. Muslims and business operators are also asked to use the fatwa as a guideline in the use of names, forms, and packaging for food, beverages, cosmetics, medicines, and other consumer goods. The government is also expected to formulate policies aligned with these provisions.
The emergence of a croissant with an appearance deemed to resemble intimate organs serves as an example of how culinary innovation can attract public attention. However, from the perspective of the MUI fatwa, the visual aspect and packaging of a product are also an important part of the halal assessment, meaning that not only the ingredients are considered in the halal certification process.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/is-the-viral-intimate-shaped-croissant-halal-check-this-mui-fatwa-for-guidance-1783867874)
Originally published by Republika (https://khazanah.republika.co.id/berita/ti2exc430/halalkah-roti-croissant-yang-viral-mirip-organ-intim-cek-fatwa-mui-ini-untuk-panduan), translated from Indonesian