IOJI pushes for effective implementation of ILO C188 Convention to protect migrant fishing vessel crews
Jakarta (ANTARA) - The Indonesia Ocean Justice Initiative (IOJI) believes the effective implementation of ILO Convention No. 188 on Work in Fishing is essential to strengthen protection for migrant fishing vessel crews (AKP).
“What we consider important is the adoption of international standards by flag states, port states and market states alike. One way is through the ratification of ILO 188,” said IOJI representative Tasya Nur Ramadhani at an online media briefing in Jakarta on Tuesday.
According to her, Indonesia has taken a positive step by ratifying ILO C188, which guarantees safe and decent working conditions in line with international standards for fishermen and migrant fishing vessel crews.
However, she said the ratification must be followed by effective implementation of the standards to deliver real protection for migrant crews.
Tasya said the series of cases affecting migrant crews, ranging from labour violations to severe exploitation and human trafficking offences (TPPO), show a recurring pattern rather than isolated incidents.
In her view, this situation is driven by inaction by various parties, including governments and businesses. On the government side, the challenges include a lack of political will to enforce the law against violations.
On the business side, low-cost business practices continue to drive the recruitment of migrant workers while disregarding human rights protections.
This involves numerous actors across the fisheries supply chain, from recruiters and vessel owners to seafood markets.
Tasya judged that low transparency and accountability remain key challenges in ensuring worker protection. She also highlighted the invisibility of migrant crews in business practices, including the use of cheap labour that is often not placed on an equal footing with national workers.
Beyond labour issues, IOJI also flagged discrimination against migrant crews through visa systems in placement countries.
Tasya said visa statuses that do not recognise crew members as workers can leave them vulnerable and dependent on employers or vessel owners.
“Discrimination based on status or type of visa can place crew members in a vulnerable position,” she said.
Crew members who hold only transit status at a port, she noted, can be treated differently from national workers. This can also limit their access to reporting violations by vessel owners or other parties.
Also found in Europe
She stressed that these problems occur not only in Asia but have also been found in Europe and the United Kingdom, according to various studies and findings by international labour organisations.
Tasya emphasised that protecting migrant crews cannot rely solely on origin or labour-sending states.
Flag, port and market states are also responsible for ensuring the protection and safety of migrant crews, she added.
“ILO 188 is important, and it is not enough for Indonesia alone as a sending state; flag states are also very important to adopt these standards,” she said.
She added that ILO C188 governs several aspects of protection, including the contents of sea employment agreements (PKL) and crew rights. However, these standards are ineffective if not applied in practice.
The complexity of migrant crews’ work, which involves both high seas and territorial waters, is a reason for Indonesia to ensure protective standards apply to Indonesian crews wherever they work.
Beyond ILO C188, IOJI also highlighted regional standards through Regional Fisheries Management Organisations (RFMOs).
Tasya cited the fisheries management organisation for the Western and Central Pacific, which has adopted legally binding labour standards provisions for states subject to those rules.
Those provisions cover minimum labour standards and High Seas Boarding Inspection mechanisms to ensure vessels meet their established commitments.
In addition, IOJI believes the handling of human trafficking cases involving migrant crews requires special attention, as they often involve many actors and countries.
Tasya explained that the cross-border nature of such cases creates challenges in identifying victims. Differing interpretations between countries on trafficking indicators can hinder victim protection and case handling.
Crew safety is also a major concern. Victims who report cases while still on board face potential threats from sharing the same environment as the perpetrators. Once ashore, they also face risks of retaliation.
The restoration of rights must also be a priority. In Tasya’s view, many migrant crews work abroad to improve their families’ economic circumstances, making redress for violated rights critically important to them.
However, cross-border case resolution often makes it difficult for victims to obtain effective remedies.
“Sometimes effective remedies are hard to achieve. One thing we consider essential for resolving trafficking cases and securing effective remedies for migrant crews is a transnational referral mechanism,” said Tasya.
Such a mechanism, she said, needs to involve the countries responsible for handling cases, with a system covering victim identification, assistance and support, law enforcement, and certainty of rights restoration.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/ioji-pushes-for-effective-implementation-of-ilo-c188-convention-to-protect-migrant-fishing-vessel-crews-1789476966)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5742361/ioji-dorong-penerapan-efektif-konvensi-ilo-c188-untuk-akp-migran), translated from Indonesian