Investment Dilemma: High Stock Appeal Hampered by Governance Issues
JAKARTA, investor.id – Indonesia’s capital market still holds strong long-term investment appeal for global investors. However, the high potential of stock appeal is overshadowed by a gap between the quality of economic opportunities and market architecture governance that has not yet met international standards.
Based on Kiwoom Research on a presentation by Director of Global Exchange Indices at S&P Dow Jones Indices (S&P DJI), Sean Freer, at the FORTUNE Investment Forum, quoted on Saturday (29/8/2026), the historical performance of Indonesian stocks has proven solid when accessed with a long-term investment horizon.
Historical data from the S&P Indonesia LargeMidCap shows that the probability of positive returns increases dramatically with longer investment periods:
1 Year: 71% probability of positive returns
3 Years: 89% probability of positive returns
5 Years: 98% probability of positive returns
10 Years: Nearly 100% probability of positive returns
Beyond price appreciation, the Indonesian market is supported by massive dividend growth. The dividend payment capacity of companies in Indonesia has expanded nearly fourfold over the past 11 years. In 2025, 104 issuers distributed dividends, of which 79 (more than 75%) managed to increase their dividend payment value.
Strategies based on environmental, social, and governance (ESG Tilting) also recorded superior performance. The S&P/IDX Indonesia ESG Tilted Index generated an excess return of +5.11% on a quarterly basis and +2.83% over one year. The average ESG score of issuers also increased significantly from 33.69 in March 2019 to 52.26 in July 2026.
Investec Asia Equity: 4.3% (vs benchmark 0.5%–0.7%)
FSSA Asian Eq Plus: 2.8% (vs benchmark 0.5%–0.7%)
Fidelity ASEAN: 15.8% (vs benchmark 6.4%–10.9%)
Barings ASEAN Frontiers: 13.8% (vs benchmark 6.4%–10.9%)
This condition indicates that professional fund managers are still able to separate macro-level market governance risks from business growth opportunities at the issuer level.
The dilemma facing Indonesia’s capital market is rooted in the transition towards deeper global financial integration. As one of the largest developing economies in Southeast Asia, Indonesia’s macroeconomic fundamentals continue to show resilience that attracts foreign investor interest.
However, this appeal now collides with increasingly stringent international transparency standards. Institutional investors not only demand high returns and dividend growth, but also require guarantees of legal certainty, minority investor protection, and accountable trading infrastructure.
Improving market architecture governance is the key to converting domestic economic potential into sustainable global capital trust.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/investment-dilemma-high-stock-appeal-hampered-by-governance-issues-1788003928)
Originally published by investor.id (https://investor.id/market/452090/dilema-investasi-daya-tarik-saham-tinggi-terganjal-masalah-tata-kelola), translated from Indonesian