Intelligence failure
Intelligence failure
For once, the Indonesian people were impressed on Sunday on
seeing that there was a functioning government in Jakarta.
Immediately following the horrific bombing incident in Bali on
Saturday night, President Megawati Soekarnoputri gathered key
members of her Cabinet for an emergency meeting at her residence
mid-morning on Sunday.
Coordinating Minister for Political and Security Affairs
Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono this time showing a more forthright
attitude and quickly issued a forceful statement that was
remarkably devoid of the vagueness and indecisiveness that have
characterized many of his statements so far.
While in Bandung, before returning to Jakarta for an emergency
Cabinet meeting, he stated: "Terrorism is right in front of our
eyes and we must take stern measures."
It was indeed a timely and appropriate decision of the
Indonesian President to immediately fly to Bali, accompanied by
senior members of her Cabinet, the Indonesian Military chief of
staff and the National Police chief, in order to see for herself
the devastation Saturday night's blast had inflicted on the area.
Certainly, the impact of the television coverage and the print
media coverage of her presence in Bali have done much to
neutralize the impression that there is no functioning government
in Indonesia.
Having noted all that, however, the urgent problem that we now
have to tackle concerns what minister Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono
referred to as "stern measures". The first and foremost problem
that comes to mind is the priority that must be given to the
collection and selecting of the available intelligence data in a
coordinated manner. Of course, it is not our intention to return
to president Soeharto's rule with its overly efficient
intelligence system. As we may recall, the bombing of one of the
stupas on an upper terrace of the Borobudur temple in
Central Java in January 1985 at that time was resolved within 48
hours.
Understandably, after President Soeharto's resignation in mid-
1998 gradually the elaborate security and intelligence system
fell into disarray. To complicate the matter, president
Soeharto's successors, president B.J. Habibie and president
Abdurrahman Wahid, kept changing the senior intelligence
officers, within the military and at the national level,
according to their own personal liking or their respective
ideological slant. The separation of the National Police from the
Indonesian Military (TNI) further slackened cooperation in
intelligence gathering its evaluation between the two.
It is not too farfetched to imagine that feelings of hurt
pride and envy have developed within the ranks of the TNI on
seeing that the National Police are now in charge of domestic
security, a domain of which until quite recently the TNI had a
major share. So, again, it is not too farfetched to imagine that
intelligence data obtained by the military intelligence
directorate pertaining to terrorist activities in Indonesia is
not readily shared with their colleagues at National Police
headquarters.
After the devastating incident in Bali over the weekend,
however, this confusion and lack of coordination in the area of
intelligence gathering and processing must end without delay. If
Gen. Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono is serious about his statement that
"stern measures" will be taken to cope with terrorist activities
in Indonesia, then he must take the initiative in establishing a
good and effective plan to coordinate intelligence gathering and
evaluation in this country.
Although Indonesia is the largest archipelagic state in the
world and has a population of more than 200 million consisting of
a wide variety of ethnic groups and religions, still, given the
open nature of the its culture, it is actually quite difficult to
keep secrets in this country. In other words, we have a strong
intuition that pieces of pertinent information are scattered here
and there related to the planning and execution of the Bali
bombing incident over the weekend. What is needed is intensive
and coordinated efforts to ferret out the relevant intelligence
information without being hampered by political and religious
considerations.
We hope that within the span of one week the government can
come up with a reasonable explanation of who the perpetrators of
the horrific events are, so that arrests can be made. If we still
are serious in seeing ourselves as a sovereign and independent
nation, what is at stake in Bali is, first and foremost, the
credibility of President Megawati's government.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/intelligence-failure-1447893297-1253041)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post