Integrating ZIS and JKN: Building a Pancasila Welfare State Architecture
Amid rising healthcare costs, ageing populations, and fiscal pressures faced by many countries, the future of the welfare state has returned to global debate. In Europe, various nations face challenges in sustaining social security financing. In the United States, healthcare costs remain a public issue. Meanwhile, in many developing countries, millions remain vulnerable to losing access to healthcare due to economic limitations.
In the midst of this debate, Indonesia actually possesses capital that many countries lack: a constitution that places social welfare as a state objective, alongside a tradition of religious philanthropy that lives and thrives within society.
Therefore, when BPJS Kesehatan initiated the use of zakat, infak, and sedekah (ZIS) funds to assist National Health Insurance (JKN) participants from poor groups who have contribution arrears, what is truly being discussed is not merely a contribution payment mechanism. What is being tested is the possibility of a new model of social protection that brings together the constitutional mandate, national mutual cooperation, and religious solidarity within a single integrated welfare architecture.
The preamble to the 1945 Constitution affirms that one of the state’s primary goals is to ‘advance public welfare’. This mandate is reinforced in Article 28H paragraph (1), which states that every person has the right to healthcare services, and Article 34 paragraph (2), which instructs the state to develop a social security system for all citizens.
On this basis, the National Social Security System (SJSN) and BPJS Kesehatan were established. Unlike commercial insurance, JKN participation is mandatory. Article 14 of Law Number 24 of 2011 concerning BPJS stipulates that every Indonesian citizen is obliged to become a participant in the social security programme.
This means that JKN contributions are not merely an administrative obligation but part of a national social contract aimed at ensuring all citizens receive sustainable health protection. Interestingly, this objective has a strong correspondence with the maqāṣid al-sharī’ah. In Islamic legal tradition, one of the primary objectives of sharia is hifẓ al-nafs, or the protection of life. Health is not merely a medical matter but part of the effort to preserve human life.
Therefore, maintaining access to healthcare for the poor is essentially a meeting point between the constitutional mandate and the objectives of sharia. If the 1945 Constitution speaks of the right to health, then maqāṣid speaks of the protection of life. Both lead to the same goal: delivering a dignified life for all citizens.
A critical issue in this discourse is determining who is entitled to receive ZIS assistance to support JKN membership. The answer cannot be subjective. It must be based on objective, transparent, and accountable welfare data.
Through the Minister of Social Affairs Decree Number 79/HUK/2025, the government uses the National Single Socio-Economic Data (DTSEN) to map community welfare levels via a decile system. Decile 1 represents the poorest 10 per cent of the population, while Decile 10 is the most prosperous group.
From both a sharia and public policy perspective, the most appropriate target group is households in Deciles 1 to 3. They are the group closest to the categories of the destitute, poor, and vulnerable poor who are confirmed to have fallen into poverty. They are also the group most at risk of losing health protection due to an inability to meet JKN contribution obligations.
This limitation is important to maintain the programme’s integrity. Unlike sadaqah and infaq funds, zakat as a religious obligation fulfilled by Muslims is essentially designated for mustahik groups who are truly in need, particularly the Muslim poor and destitute. Therefore, the use of DTSEN not only strengthens social accountability but also reinforces sharia legitimacy through a more objective mechanism for identifying mustahik in accordance with sharia, as stipulated in specific regulations and sharia governance prepared by BPJS Kesehatan together with the MUI Fatwa Commission, with implementation overseen by a Sharia Supervisor.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/integrating-zis-and-jkn-building-a-pancasila-welfare-state-architecture-1783911111)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/ti3do7475/integrasi-zis-dan-jkn-membangun-arsitektur-negara-kesejahteraan-pancasila), translated from Indonesian