Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Integrated National Schools: Do Not Repeat Past Mistakes

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
Integrated National Schools: Do Not Repeat Past Mistakes
Image: Republika

The government is once again showing courage in making a breakthrough in education through the Integrated National Schools (SNT) programme. Through Presidential Instruction Number 10 of 2026, the government is targeting the construction of 500 SNT by 2029 as centres for equalising the quality of education. This policy deserves appreciation because it demonstrates a shift in the orientation of education development, from merely expanding access to improving the quality of learning. For years, Indonesia has successfully increased school participation rates. However, the main problem in national education is no longer the number of children attending school, but rather the persistent gap in quality between regions. On one hand, schools in major cities have quality teachers, complete laboratories, and adequate access to technology. On the other hand, many schools in the regions are still struggling to meet basic learning needs. This disparity hinders the birth of superior and evenly distributed human resources. SNT offers an approach that integrates junior and senior secondary schools into a single educational ecosystem. This integration allows for the shared use of facilities, teacher development, student talent coaching, and the strengthening of unique characteristics according to regional potential—a far more comprehensive idea than simply building new schools.

Support for SNT must not make us ignore important lessons from the past. Indonesian education has never lacked programmes born with great intentions. Various policies, from international-standard schools, reference schools, vocational school revitalisation, school digitalisation, to various learning transformation programmes, were once launched with high optimism. In reality, some had a positive impact, but many lost momentum when they entered the implementation stage. The problem is the same: programmes are designed very well, but their execution does not meet expectations. Inter-agency coordination weakens, leadership changes alter priorities, the quality of human resources is not ready, and evaluation focuses more on administrative achievements than on the real impact on learning quality. Pressman and Wildavsky (1984) long reminded us that implementation is the most decisive stage in the success of public policy. No matter how well a policy is designed, the outcome will depend heavily on the ability of implementers to translate it in the field. Mazmanian and Sabatier (1983) also emphasised that successful implementation is determined by clarity of objectives, organisational capacity, political support, and the commitment of implementers. Without these, even a good policy can lose its direction.

Five things need to be anticipated. First, the government must ensure that SNT does not develop into ‘quality islands’. The success of these schools should not only be measured by their students’ achievements, but by their ability to improve the quality of surrounding schools. SNT must become centres for sharing good practices, teacher development, shared laboratories, and learning innovation for the entire region. If neighbouring schools remain left behind, the goal of SNT has not truly been achieved. Second, the biggest investment must be given to teachers. Buildings can be constructed in a short time, but a professional culture requires a long process. Michael Fullan reminds us that educational change ultimately depends on changes in teachers’ teaching practices. Continuous coaching, learning communities, and principal leadership must be top priorities. Third, governance must be designed simply and clearly. SNT will involve the central government, local governments, universities, the business world, and the community. Without a firm division of roles, coordination can become a hindrance. Experience shows that many national programmes lose momentum because each party feels they are only a supporter, not the main responsible party. Fourth, digitalisation must not stop at providing devices. Smart classrooms, modern laboratories, and the use of artificial intelligence will not have a significant impact if teachers lack adequate digital pedagogical competence. Technology is just a tool; the quality of learning is still determined by how teachers use it. Fifth, the government needs to establish success measures that truly reflect change. Evaluation cannot stop at the number of buildings completed or students admitted. Success indicators must include improvements in literacy, numeracy, character, teacher quality, and the quality of schools around the SNT.

Consistency determines the future. Peter Senge (1990), through the concept of the learning organisation, asserts that successful organisations are not those that never make mistakes, but those that continuously learn and improve. This principle should be the spirit of SNT implementation. The government needs to open up space for honest evaluation, involving universities, professional organisations, local governments, and the community so that every problem can be immediately corrected before it becomes a policy failure. What the public will remember in the future is not the number of schools successfully built, but the extent to which this policy is able to produce more professional teachers, schools that strengthen each other, and students who receive quality learning opportunities without being limited by the place they were born. If implementation consistency can be maintained, SNT has the potential to become an important milestone in equalising the quality of Indonesian education. However, if attention stops only at physical construction and ceremonies, we are merely repeating old mistakes.

More from 4 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/integrated-national-schools-do-not-repeat-past-mistakes-1785822752)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/tj80ui368/sekolah-nasional-terintegrasi-jangan-mengulang-kesalahan-lama), translated from Indonesian
Print