Inheritance and Gifting of Shares Could Become a Time Bomb
Shares can be inherited or gifted, but there are limitations. Shares are not merely investment instruments that can be traded, but are also movable assets that can be objects of inheritance and gifts. In the context of a limited liability company, share ownership is attached to the legal subject recorded as a shareholder.
Therefore, when an individual owns shares in a company, the rights attached to those shares—ranging from dividend rights and voting rights in a General Meeting of Shareholders (Gemma) to other rights provided by law—can, in principle, be transferred to heirs. However, it is crucial to identify who is legally recorded as the shareholder. For instance, if shares in Company X are owned by Company ABC, what is inherited is not the shares of Company X directly, but rather the individual’s ownership in Company ABC and the rights attached to that ownership.
The transfer of shares through inheritance also differs from general share transactions. Inheritance is a transfer by law; thus, in principle, heirs do not necessarily have to offer the shares to other shareholders or seek approval from the company’s organs, provided there are no legal provisions preventing the heir from receiving the inheritance.
Nevertheless, not all shares can automatically become objects of inheritance. Shares that do not legally constitute the ownership of an individual cannot be inherited as the personal property of a shareholder. This highlights the importance of distinguishing between corporate assets and personal ownership rights in a company, especially when the ownership structure involves a legal entity as a shareholder.
What is the difference between inheritance and the gifting of shares? Inheritance essentially takes effect after the shareholder passes away, based on either inheritance laws or a will. In contrast, a gift (hibah) allows shares to be transferred while the donor is still alive. Recipients of gifted shares may even be outside the donor’s lineage, but this freedom is not unlimited. Both share gifts and testamentary gifts must respect the ‘legitieme portie’, which is the absolute portion legally protected for certain heirs.
In other words, a shareholder’s desire to determine who will receive their shares must not ignore the rights of heirs protected by law. When the value of shares within a family reaches a significant amount, understanding the boundaries between inheritance, gifts, and the ‘legitieme portie’ becomes increasingly important so that wealth planning does not turn into a family dispute in the future.
‘Legitieme Portie’ as a Fortress for Shareholders’ Heirs. In the concept of civil inheritance law, the ‘legitieme portie’ is an absolute portion of the estate that must be protected for heirs in a direct line. This means that while shareholders have the freedom to determine to whom their assets are given through gifts or wills, this freedom is not absolute.
For non-Muslim decedents, the Indonesian Civil Code (KUHPerdata) regulates the amount of the ‘legitieme portie’ based on the number of children: 1/2 if there is one child, 2/3 if there are two children, and 3/4 if there are three or more children, calculated from the portion they would otherwise receive under inheritance provisions. Meanwhile, for Muslim decedents, there is a limit of 1/3, as known in the Compilation of Islamic Law.
Therefore, the ‘legitieme portie’ serves as a critical boundary when making share gifts. A shareholder cannot simply gift all or most of their shares to a specific party if such an action ultimately reduces the absolute rights of the legally protected heirs.
The issue becomes even more complex when the gifted shares hold significant economic value or serve as the primary source of control over a company. A gift intended as wealth planning or legacy sustainability can instead become a source of conflict if executed without considering the rights of other heirs. If a gift or testamentary gift results in a violation of the heirs’ ‘legitimie portie’, the aggrieved heirs have the right to seek legal protection through the courts.
The goal is not necessarily to annul the gift, but to ensure that the minimum portion belonging to the heirs remains protected. Thus, before gifting shares, especially those of significant value, shareholders need to calculate the legal consequences for the estate. Decisions made to distribute shares today should not become the beginning of an inheritance dispute in the future.
Preventing Disputes Before Shares are Inherited or Gifted. Planning the gifting of shares should not stop at the shareholder’s mere desire. Although a gift is fundamentally the will of the donor, transparency with all heirs is a strategic step to prevent future disputes. Therefore, the consent and acceptance of the heirs should be clearly stated in a deed of gift prepared before a notary. This step provides certainty regarding the donor’s intent and reduces the potential for objections after the gift is made.
Should a dispute still arise and lead to court, the ‘legitieme portie’ will be a key factor in determining whether the gift has reduced the absolute rights of the shareholders’ heirs.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/inheritance-and-gifting-of-shares-could-become-a-time-bomb-1791359727)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20261007141505-14-774104/waris-dan-hibah-saham-bisa-menjadi-bom-waktu), translated from Indonesian