Indonesia’s Vice-President Resigns After Falling Out of Step with the President
Indonesia was thrown into turmoil when Mohammad Hatta formally resigned as vice-president on 1 December 1956, having fallen out of step with President Sukarno. Bung Hatta chose to relinquish his office, bringing the partnership known as the “Dwitunggal” to an end.
The news caused a stir in the parliamentary chambers, although it had been circulating for some time. Hatta had already submitted his resignation in 1955, but parliament did not act on it.
Differences of opinion, the limited scope of his role and rampant corruption made it difficult for Hatta to remain in office. What disappointed him most about Sukarno, his friend, was the Guided Democracy system championed by the president.
Hatta resigned because he and President Sukarno held opposing views on the system of government. Hatta supported parliamentary democracy, while Sukarno promoted the contrasting concept of Guided Democracy.
Hatta believed Sukarno had departed substantially from the commitments the president and vice-president had made in 1945 and 1949, both politically and in the way the country was governed. The Dwitunggal partnership was no longer aligned, and Hatta’s views could not readily be reconciled with Sukarno’s.
Hatta also chose to resign because he disagreed with the constitutional system governing the vice-president’s role at the time. He believed that the parliamentary system, which gave the prime minister a greater role as head of government, left the vice-president with a limited and ineffective position.
Beyond the system of government, Hatta felt unable to halt increasingly widespread corruption within the administration. His resignation left Sukarno to govern without a vice-president, paving the way for Sukarno’s political dominance and more centralised policies.
In his essay Demokrasi Kita (Our Democracy), Hatta wrote that the “Guided Democracy” formulated by Sukarno would last only as long as the head of state. “The consequence of leading is suffering.” Hatta understood the phrase deeply.
After returning to ordinary life as a citizen, Hatta continued to criticise policies he considered misguided and harmful to the Indonesian people. One example was the government’s response to soaring inflation, which had reached 650 per cent.
Mochtar Lubis wrote in Hati Nurani Melawan Kezaliman, Surat-surat Bung Hatta kepada Presiden Soekarno 1957–1965 (Conscience Against Tyranny: Bung Hatta’s Letters to President Sukarno, 1957–1965, 1986) that Hatta himself struggled to meet his family’s day-to-day living costs.
In a letter to Sukarno dated 17 June 1963, Hatta expressed his anxiety about the country’s future:
“Our goal is socialism, but the government’s economic mismanagement has created a new capitalist class that sees itself as an ‘elite’, lives luxuriously and considers itself indispensable to government figures at both central and regional levels. The contrast between rich and poor is glaring; it has never been as sharp as it is now” (Lubis, 1986: 81).
Nevertheless, the two national figures maintained a warm relationship. On 12 July 1963, for example, President Sukarno visited Hatta, who was seriously ill in Jakarta’s central public hospital. The visit showed that, despite following different paths, they shared an underlying goal: national unity and progress.
Hatta consistently offered the government solutions, believing it was not doing enough to ease the people’s suffering. Deliar Noer (1990: 669) quotes Hatta’s remarks on the moral decline preceding the fall of the Old Order: “We have always condemned the principle of l’exploitation de l’homme par l’homme that prevailed under colonial imperialism. But we must not replace that evil principle in our Republic of Indonesia with an even worse system: l’exploitation de l’homme par l’État — the exploitation of people by the state.”
Hatta’s commitment to the people’s fundamental rights continued into the New Order. He believed that the main duty of a democratic leader was to consider who would succeed them, rather than how to retain power indefinitely.
In Biografi Politik Muhammad Hatta (The Political Biography of Muhammad Hatta), Mavis Rose notes that one form of political participation by the West Sumatra-born figure was submitting a petition to the House of Representatives asserting that the New Order had disregarded Pancasila and the 1945 Constitution.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/indonesias-vice-president-resigns-after-falling-out-of-step-with-the-president-1794293453)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/to9w0s282/wapres-ri-resmi-mundur-karena-sudah-tak-sejalan-dengan-presiden), translated from Indonesian