Indonesia's rights crimes must be heeded
Indonesia's rights crimes must be heeded
This is the second of two articles on crimes against humanity
by Vanessa Johanson, an adviser to the National Commission on
Human Rights in Jakarta (Komnas HAM).
JAKARTA (JP): Extraordinary crimes require extraordinary
responses. Thus, although of course murder, torture, rape,
arbitrary detention and other such crimes have long been illegal
in Indonesia, no matter whether they are perpetrated by civilians
or state apparatus, the Human Rights Court Act was established to
address the problem that when these crimes are carried out on a
large scale, particularly by state functionaries, the
perpetrators are almost never punished.
As Human Rights Watch states in reference to the Rome Statute,
"Until recently, it seemed that if you killed one person, you
went to jail, but if you slaughtered thousands, you usually got
away it. Times change."
When the Human Rights Court Act was passed in Indonesia it
seemed as if times might be changing. So where are the Human
Rights Courts? The establishment and use of the Courts have faced
a number of obstacles which must be overcome if Indonesia is to
become a country which respects the rule of law, and where
democracy is not continually undermined by violence, state-
sponsored or otherwise.
Some of the obstacles are legal. Not long before the Human
Rights Court Act was passed, the People's Consultative Assembly
made a Second Amendment to the Indonesian Constitution which
outlawed the hearing of any legal cases retroactively. For the
Human Rights Courts, this means that violations perpetrated
before the passing of the Act on Nov. 23, 2000, will be almost
impossible to bring to Court.
This is true even though the Act allows for the establishment
of Ad Hoc Courts for crimes which occurred before the passing of
the Act, because defendants' lawyers will be able to claim that
the Constitution is a higher law than the Act. This can be
overcome, however, because crimes against humanity are recognized
as crimes under international customary law, so that whether
written or not, they are illegal everywhere and at all times,
regardless of retroactivity provisions.
Another problem with the Act is its narrow jurisdiction in
terms of the types of crimes it covers. It only covers "gross
violations of human rights" which it defines as "genocide" and
"crimes against humanity." As stated above, it omits to mention
the other two crimes which are vital to thorough coverage of
gross violations.
It also fails to mention violations which are not necessarily
widespread or systematic (as they must be to be termed "crimes
against humanity"), thus omitting the thousands if not millions
of incidences of murder, rape, torture, arbitrary detention,
kidnapping and so on carried out on an individual basis at police
stations, military operations, prisons, demonstrations, homes,
streets and forests all over Indonesia for decades.
Where will the victims of these crimes find justice? Certainly
not in the regular court system which aside from remaining
riddled with corruption and subject to political pressure, is
also jammed with a backlog of thousands of cases at every level.
Crimes against humanity and other gross violations of human
rights are regarded as crimes greater and worse than regular
crimes covered in the Penal Code (and are therefore regarded as
extraordinary crimes), and therefore do require a separate legal
process. But when the Penal Code and Military Penal Code
themselves are not upheld and impunity continues, the potential
for regular crimes to become extraordinary crimes is enormous.
The main problem with the implementation of the Human Rights
Court Act, however, is not legal but political. The Act provides
for command responsibility, that is, not only does it hold the
immediate perpetrator of a crime in the field responsible for
his/her actions, but also his or her superiors and the policy-
makers which commissioned the act or allowed it to happen by
willful omission.
This has naturally rung alarm bells in the ranks of the
Indonesian security forces, and prompted them to be less than
cooperative and even actively hinder the preparatory work of the
Human Rights Courts. During the investigations by Komnas HAM's
Commission of Inquiry into Human Rights in Irian Jaya/Papua, for
example, witnesses already interviewed by the Komnas HAM were
then interrogated and intimidated by the local police, who also
engaged in a public war of words on the legitimacy and competence
of the Komnas HAM team.
Many of the cases likely to be brought to the Human Rights
Courts are sensitive in terms of the concept of the Indonesian
nation and are entangled in the current popular discourse of
disintegrasi, a term used to describe the sense of the collapse
of national unity, which in fact is more a metaphysical than a
geographical collapse.
The East Timor case, for example, which is due to be heard in
an Ad Hoc Human Rights Court in July, is sensitive not only
because it implicates senior military and civilian personnel, but
also because it stirs up anger and emotion about the separation
of East Timor from Indonesia. In the minds of many, the crimes
committed were justified in the name of the very meaning of
Indonesia, that is, a sprawling but nevertheless unified nation.
The myth of the military as the creators and unifiers of the
Indonesian nation is also at stake.
Other cases threaten the national ideology in another way. The
mass state-sponsored killings of supposed Communists in 1965, and
the subsequent arbitrary detention of hundreds of thousands more
accused of being Communists, are undoubtedly Crimes against
Humanity on a large scale. However, legal resolution of this case
remains extremely unlikely, as Communism remains illegal in
Indonesia. As we have seen this last week with the police raid on
an Asia Pacific Workers' conference in Jakarta, the imaginary
threat from "leftist" ideas is increasingly once again being
exploited for political purposes.
None of these obstacles are insurmountable in the new
Indonesia. An international workshop to be held at the Attorney
General's offices in Jakarta on June 20-21 on Crimes against
Humanity will provide an international perspective on human
rights justice in Indonesia. It will bring together a number of
international and national experts to explore how to best
overcome the above problems. It is hoped that with such a
Workshop, the wheels of justice will begin to turn in Indonesia.
It is also hoped that Indonesia will be able to add new
innovations to the international fight against crimes against
humanity, for example by better incorporating violence against
women and even looking at long term effects of development
policies as crimes against humanity.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/indonesias-rights-crimes-must-be-heeded-1447893297-1081762)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post