Indonesia's future economic challenges
Indonesia's future economic challenges
This is the second of two articles by Dr. Emil Salim,
professor of economics at the University of Indonesia and
chairman of the former National Economic Council. This article is
based on a presentation at an international conference on
Indonesia held last month in Tokyo. The event was hosted by the
Ministry of Finance.
TOKYO: The pendulum of development is swinging from
centralization towards decentralization -- and from unity focused
development to diversity focused development.
Indonesians comprise a few races and many ethnic groups, which
have unique customary laws, distinct institutions and village
structures that claim ownership over the land, sea and forests.
This claim is however not formally recognized, since the
customary law is unwritten. Development has led many among these
ethnic groups to migrate to various other regions. To reduce
population pressures, the program of transmigration was launched.
Human settlements for incoming migrants were built with
government support.
When the economy grows and everybody is well off, this kind of
development can take place without significant social conflict
erupting. However as we have seen, when an economic crisis breaks
out, competition for land, forests and other natural resources,
as well as jobs, becomes fierce and open, and frictions and
conflicts emerge.
As the government's authority is weakened due to the change in
regime, various ethnic groups rally around unifying
characteristics, such as religion, ethnicity, race or specific
communal groups to strengthen solidarity. Any small incident
among people of different communal groups is enough to escalate
full-blown conflict.
Indonesia is suffering a "vertical conflict" between the
central government and locals in the provinces of Aceh and Irian
Jaya; "social conflicts" involving religion in Maluku and Central
Sulawesi; conflicts using symbols of ethnicity in West and
Central Kalimantan; racial conflict in Jakarta, May 1998 and
conflicts using political symbols in East Java.
The government usually approaches these situations in a heavy-
handed way. It would be more appropriate to apply an interest-
based approach on conflict management and conflict resolution,
trying to resolve conflicts by meeting the conflicting parties'
respective interests. This can be accomplished along the modern
and traditional consensus-building musyawarah or the Islamic
approach (Islah).
The economic crisis has raised the veil covering the unequal
playing field between social groups. It has also raised awareness
to pursue a more equitable pattern of development among regions
and communities through affirmative policies.
Development strategies neglecting social factors have paid a
high price through the physical destruction of cities and
settlements. But the highest price of all has been the social
disintegration of a nation committed to unity in diversity.
During the New Order regime, development was based on the
market economy, i.e. dispersion of economic decision-making by
the public through the market. This development was not
accompanied by a similar process of political decision-making by
the public. As the economy grew rapidly, political development
was left behind, and tension was bound to grow.
The combination of such developments was one of the many
driving forces that created the economic crisis, which soon grew
into a social and political crisis. This created the need for a
comprehensive solution encompassing economic, social and
political factors.
Since the change of regime in May 1998, the main development
in society has been the aim of comprehensive total reform, known
as reformasi. Its key points include the following:
First, the shift from authoritarian rule to democracy. This is
clearly revealed in the growth of political parties, labor
unions, community organizations etc., supported by a free press
and public rallies as a means of free expression. The most
important development is the revolt of the legislature from its
previous image of being a "rubber stamp" government, subordinate
to the President.
Second, a shift from centralization to decentralization in
government and development. Decentralization caters to the
demands for diversity within the context of one nation, with the
central government left with the responsibility for major
functions such as foreign affairs, defense, the judiciary and
religion. Under decentralization, regions control natural
resources under their jurisdiction, and can launch their own
pattern of development. The coordinating role of the central
government is to prevent the fragmentation of the economy into
uneconomic compartments.
Third, a shift from the law of rulers to the rule of law. The
rulers were backed by a powerful military apparatus stretching
from the center of power down to the village level, based on the
dual functional role of military and political development.
The thrust is now to demilitarize government along with the
separation of power between the executive, legislative and
judiciary bodies. Supremacy of the law is the goal of reformasi,
perhaps the most difficult of aims following decades of judicial
erosion.
Fourth, the shift from a bias toward conglomerates to a
populist style of development. The introduction of the anti-
monopoly law aims to prevent monopolistic business practices. It
is significant that debt registered by the Indonesian Bank
Restructuring Agency is largely concentrated in the hands of just
21 entities.
Affirmative action is moving toward small and medium
enterprises, which were the most resilient during the crisis and
are a major force in exports.
Fifth, the shift from coopting to empowering civil society.
This has resulted in new bodies such as Corruption Watch,
Parliament Watch, Human Right Watch, etc. The goal is to obtain a
balance of power between the government, politicians, business
and civil society.
In this transitional period there are of course forces at work
to resist and reject reformasi. Many of these goals still seem
far away, creating doubts as to whether they are in fact
achievable. The reform movement moves erratically and rather
chaotically in the absence of strong leadership. It has created
anxiety and confusion over the direction of Indonesia's
development.
Given the above five features of the reform movement, short-
term aims to solve the crisis should be pursued:
* In the economy, an agreement needs to be reached with the
International Monetary Fund to recapture market confidence;
* On the social front, start mediation to search for conflict
resolution and reconciliation in crucial regions;
* On the political front, settle the tug-of-war between the
President and the legislature in the coming August session of the
People's Consultative Assembly.
To conclude: We need to fasten our seat belts and pray for the
best, but prepare for the worst.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/indonesias-future-economic-challenges-1447893297-1115255)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post