Indonesians’ Lifestyle Downgrading Sparks Debate; IPB Professor Offers Unexpected Explanation
Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia — The trend of downgrading one’s lifestyle is now widely discussed among Indonesians, particularly on social media. Cutting spending and switching to cheaper products is seen as one sign of the economic pressure facing the middle class.
IPB University consumer behaviour expert Prof Megawati Simanjuntak said these lifestyle changes are not always driven by a desire to save, but may also reflect constraints on household finances. In family and consumer sciences, she said, the phenomenon is known as a coping strategy: a way of adapting to hardship in order to get by.
“In family and consumer sciences, this is called a coping strategy: a way for families to adapt so they can continue to get by. Saving money and switching to cheaper products are part of that effort, alongside seeking additional income,” Megawati said in an official statement from IPB University, cited on Sunday (8 November 2026).
She said there were two notable aspects to the trend. First, lifestyle downgrading is now common among the middle class, which has generally been considered relatively secure economically. Second, people are increasingly open about discussing these changes on social media, and even turning them into content.
“Previously, someone might have kept it to themselves if they replaced café coffee with instant sachet coffee. Now, they tell people about it,” she said.
Megawati said the current trend is largely not simply a choice to live modestly, but is driven by economic necessity. People’s incomes have not risen significantly, while the prices of everyday necessities continue to increase.
Household finances are further squeezed by loan repayments.
“From the outside, the saving behaviour looks the same, but the reasons behind it may differ. If it is a conscious effort to manage finances, it can be positive because it reduces the pressure to shop for status. But if it is due to a family’s dwindling financial resilience, that is a warning sign,” she explained.
The situation is more precarious because middle-income groups generally have limited access to social assistance. As a result, some people risk slipping into a lower economic position.
In addition to pressure from expenses, concerns about layoffs and difficulties finding work are prompting people to curb spending and build up emergency savings.
Potential impact on Indonesia’s economy
Megawati warned that the trend affects not only household finances but could also have implications for the national economy. As the middle class cuts spending, demand could fall in sectors including restaurants, cafés, shopping centres, fashion, tourism, entertainment, automotive and property.
The effects could also spread to micro, small and medium-sized enterprises (MSMEs), which employ a large number of workers.
“This situation risks creating a mutually reinforcing cycle of weakness. Lower spending can put pressure on the incomes of workers in affected sectors. When their incomes also decline, households cut spending again, further weakening consumption,” she said.
Lifestyle downgrading can nevertheless have some positive effects. In the short term, people may improve their savings and switch to more affordable local products.
However, if the trend persists over the longer term because of economic pressure, household consumption—which is one of the pillars of the national economy—could weaken. Megawati said whether lifestyle downgrading becomes a lasting habit will depend heavily on future economic conditions.
If the pressure is temporary, people may increase their spending again as conditions improve. But if income growth continues to lag behind the rising cost of living, the habit of saving money could last longer.
“This is not about the middle class being unwilling to spend, but about their ability to do so and whether they feel secure. If we want their consumption to recover, the key is restoring purchasing power and confidence in the outlook, not simply urging them to start spending again,” she stressed.
Megawati therefore said the government needed to ensure that people downgraded their lifestyles as a conscious choice, rather than because they were forced to by economic pressure.
“Strong purchasing power and good employment opportunities remain key,” she said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/indonesians-lifestyle-downgrading-sparks-debate-ipb-professor-offers-unexpected-explanation-1794120634)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/lifestyle/20261108062531-33-783241/heboh-warga-ri-downgrade-lifestyle-ungkapan-profesor-ipb-tak-terduga), translated from Indonesian