Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Indonesian Tax Disputes Surge, with Five Issues Most Frequently Challenged

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Finance
Indonesian Tax Disputes Surge, with Five Issues Most Frequently Challenged
Image: CNBC Indonesia

Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia — Tax disputes in Indonesia continue to be dominated by technical issues involving audits, income reporting and differing interpretations of tax rules. Data from the Finance Ministry’s Directorate General of Taxes (DJP) show that five main issues are the most common sources of disputes between taxpayers and the tax authority.

Director General of Taxes Bimo Wijayanto said that, according to data covering 2021 to the third quarter of 2026, there were 73,394 tax appeals and lawsuits nationwide.

The DJP identified several issues that most often form the basis of disputes at the Tax Court. The largest category concerns methods and techniques for testing the relationship between items, accounting for 25.59% of cases.

“The first is the method and technique for testing relationships. This requires a methodology to examine accounts, the evidence supporting the accounts, accounting practices and standards, and the reconciliation of accounting with taxation,” Bimo said in a presentation at the Supreme Court.

The second issue is income or supplies that were not, or were under-reported, withheld or collected. This category accounts for 17.29% of the cases analysed.

Bimo said transaction evidence was crucial in determining whether tax had been reported correctly in such cases.

“Evidence from transaction data, cash flows, the movement of money and the movement of goods is key and will serve as proof,” he said.

Third are disputes prompted by differing interpretations of tax provisions, accounting for 11.75%. Such differences are a source of conflict between taxpayers and the DJP when determining tax liabilities.

Fourth are disputes over Value Added Tax (VAT), which make up 9.95% of the cases analysed.

Bimo said VAT disputes generally involve reconciling input tax with output tax. One issue is claims for refunds of input tax that are considered not to meet formal or substantive requirements.

There are also cases in which input tax is deemed not to have a direct connection with a company’s business activities.

“There are many motives of this kind. They do not only fall within the administrative sphere; if criminal intent can be proven, they can also be treated as tax crimes,” Bimo said.

Fifth are disputes related to transfer pricing and secondary adjustments, accounting for 8.3%. These concern cross-border transactions, particularly those involving affiliated companies.

Bimo highlighted practices involving the allocation of costs and the shifting of profits through transactions between related companies. One example is charging marketing fees in Indonesia while centralising marketing activities in another country that offers tax incentives.

He cited Singapore as a country that offers tax incentives to marketing offices under certain conditions. Such practices, he said, can shift company profits abroad while costs are charged in Indonesia, leaving the company to record a loss domestically.

Bimo said transfer pricing and misinvoicing were no longer merely domestic issues and required coordination between countries.

Transfer pricing and misinvoicing have also been raised in bilateral discussions between Indonesia and Singapore.

The five issues illustrate the range of challenges in resolving tax disputes, from technical audit and administrative matters to increasingly complex cross-border transactions.

More from 5 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/indonesian-tax-disputes-surge-with-five-issues-most-frequently-challenged-1793854246)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20261105100757-4-782519/sengketa-pajak-ri-meledak-ini-5-masalah-yang-paling-banyak-digugat), translated from Indonesian
Print