Indonesian Editors Forum Rebukes Hotman Paris for Disrespecting Journalist
Remarks made by prominent lawyer Hotman Paris Hutapea to a journalist during a press conference at the Attorney General’s Office have drawn a strong backlash. Beyond sparking debate on social media, the incident has also drawn the attention of the Editors-in-Chief Forum (Forum Pemred), which judged the attitude to reflect a lack of respect for the journalistic profession.
Forum Pemred even issued an official statement expressing regret while urging all parties to respect the work of journalists carrying out their duties in accordance with the Press Law.
The controversy arose after Hotman Paris accompanied former Deputy Attorney General for Special Crimes (Jampidsus) Febrie Adriansyah, who was questioned as a suspect at the Attorney General’s Office building in Jakarta on Friday, 17 July 2026.
After his client’s questioning concluded, Hotman Paris gave a statement to members of the media. During the question-and-answer session, one journalist’s question was met with a remark that quickly went viral.
“Do you have a brain?” Hotman said.
The remark spread rapidly across social media and prompted a wide range of reactions. Many considered the response failed to address the substance of the journalist’s question and instead came across as a personal attack.
In response to the incident, Forum Pemred issued an official statement deploring Hotman Paris’s attitude and the manner in which he responded to the journalist’s question.
According to Forum Pemred, an interviewee does have the right not to answer a question. However, that right should not be exercised through words or behaviour that demean the journalistic profession.
Forum Pemred assessed that both the choice of words and the gestures displayed at the press conference reflected a lack of respect for journalistic work.
In its statement, Forum Pemred emphasised that asking questions is a fundamental part of the journalistic process.
Questions posed by journalists serve to seek confirmation, gather information and uphold the principle of verification before information is published to the public.
For that reason, the organisation deemed a response such as “do you have a brain”, accompanied by what was perceived as arrogant behaviour, to be inappropriate towards a journalist carrying out professional duties.
Forum Pemred also judged the action failed to address the substance of the questions raised at the press conference. It reminded the public that journalistic work in Indonesia enjoys legal protection under Law No. 40 of 1999 on the Press.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/indonesian-editors-forum-rebukes-hotman-paris-for-disrespecting-journalist-1784469071)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1914718-forum-pemred-tegur-keras-sikap-hotman-paris-minta-hormati-profesi-wartawan), translated from Indonesian