Indonesian Diaspora Opposes Proposal to Restrict Access to Social Welfare in Australia
Several Indonesian nationals who hold permanent resident status in Australia oppose proposals from the Australian opposition to limit access to social welfare. The Opposition in Australia is known as the Coalition, comprising the Liberal Party and the Australian National Party. They have proposed restricting access to at least 17 social services in Australia, including the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS), parental leave, and caregiver allowances.
“If you are not an Australian citizen, you do not receive the privileges of being Australian,” said Australian Opposition Leader, Angus Taylor. “When you commit to this country, we will commit to you.”
Under the proposal, the NDIS would be restricted to Australian citizens and would remain available to those who have already accessed it. The plan, according to Angus, would save “billions of dollars” over the coming years, but he said a detailed cost estimate would be released ahead of the upcoming general election.
Nila Halim, an Indonesian-citizen mother living in Melbourne, Australia, is one of the permanent residents who disagree with the proposal. Nila said that when she first arrived in Australia and had not yet become a permanent resident, she had to “scrape coins from her husband’s pocket just to buy snacks.” Since becoming a permanent resident, Nila, who has four children under 18, has been able to receive the Family Tax Benefit. One Family Tax Benefit scheme is targeted at families with after-tax income below AU$80,000 (Rp100 million). Nila also receives assistance from the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) and the carer allowance to care for one of her children with Down syndrome. Through the NDIS, Nila received AU$50,000 (Rp631 million) over two years, or AU$25,000 (Rp315 million) for one year. The average NDIS package per recipient in 2025 was just under AU$66,700 (Rp841 million), while the median package was AU$19,300 (Rp243 million). Nila said the assistance she receives “is enough to keep us afloat.” “The Opposition’s proposal to tighten welfare access for new permanent residents makes me fear,” she said. “Not as a political opinion, but as someone who has experienced vulnerability, which they now want to spread to others.” She argued that permanent residents in Australia should be able to access social services. Moreover, she contended that anyone who pays taxes in Australia, regardless of citizenship status, should not be discriminated against in receiving government assistance and benefits. “In my view, the government assistance provided through social services should be given because permanent residents pay the same taxes as citizens,” she said. “If that restriction happens, it would be a big loss for Australia.” “My child was born with Down syndrome, and I did not know it during pregnancy,” she said. “When she was born, we were fortunate because Australia’s early intervention system exists, but we still waited eight months to access the NDIS.” “We managed to get through this, but I often think of families who are in exactly the same situation as ours.” “It’s sad for them.” Reinita Silitonga, known as Nita, has been a permanent resident of Australia for 20 years. Amid rising living costs, Nita says she cannot imagine permanent residents in Australia losing access to social services. “I think if they come here and already have PR, but suddenly cannot access childcare, parenting payment, JobSeeker, what can they do if they lose their jobs?” she said. “It may not affect me, but I feel sorry for them; they worked hard to obtain PR, and now the costs are not small, right?” The cost of applying for permanent Australian citizenship is at least AU$4,910 (Rp61 million), excluding health checks, English language tests, and other requirements. As a single parent, Nita says she has benefited from Australia’s social services while raising her child. After separating from her former husband in 2009, she says she was once dismissed from her job. While seeking new employment for six weeks, she received rental assistance, in addition to the Family Tax Benefit and Parenting Payment (Single) to raise her three-and-a-half-year-old child. “It would be very hard without Centrelink support, especially if we were still renting,” she said. “I think it’s unfair if someone just got PR and then they split from their husband, have no backup, no job; that would be hard.” The leader of the Opposition Coalition, Angus Taylor, said that to access the social services, a permanent resident can become an Australian citizen. “Ultimately they can become citizens,” said Angus. He emphasised that healthcare services would remain available to non-citizens as well, and said that should be sufficient. “We already have good healthcare services to handle such situations for a long time,” he said. If one wishes to become an Australian citizen, Indonesian citizens must renounce their nationality, because Indonesia does not recognise dual citizenship. That is not an easy decision for Nita. “I cannot renounce my Indonesian citizenship… my parents are dead, and I still have siblings and property in Indonesia,” she said. “If something happens, I could not return home immediately, and I would lose inheritance rights.” According to her, migrants also
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/indonesian-diaspora-opposes-proposal-to-restrict-access-to-social-welfare-in-australia-1779542657)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/abc-australia/d-8498568/diaspora-ri-menentang-proposal-membatasi-akses-jaminan-sosial-di-australia), translated from Indonesian