Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Indonesia is

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Indonesia is
over-bureaucratized

I am not an expert in organizational matters and what I am
going to write is just my feeling. I am sure that the majority of
my fellow citizens are also not experts in this field, but I am
sure that they are also feeling confused with what is happening
in Indonesia, and the common feeling is that Indonesia is over-
bureaucratized.

I read in a book entitled Partai-partai politik di Indonesia
(Political parties in Indonesia) compiled by Kompas. It said that
after Soeharto stepped down on May 21, 1998, at least 80
political parties registered at the Home Ministry over the next
five months. After serious research done by Kompas, the number
grew to 141 political parties. For me this is no proof of the
existence of a good democracy, but on the contrary, proof of a
tragically divided nation.

This large number shows an unhealthy political ambition.
Everybody wants to get an important political position but
without the sense of responsibility inherent with such an
important position.

Any time something goes wrong, then many people find it
necessary to create commissions or committees with tasks that are
already covered by existing government institutions. But if we
are honest, then you can understand (not always meaning to agree)
the demand for the creation of committees, with jobs which are
already supposed to be done by government institutions, like in
cases of corruption, which is supposed to be taken care of by the
Attorney General, the Police and finally the courts. These
institutions and many others are not setting a good example of
efficiency, expertise or a sense of responsibility. In the case
of fighting corruption, the integrity of an official must be
considered as an absolute prerequisite because efficiency alone
does not ensure success.

An Islamic scholar by the name of Abdul Rahman bin Khaldun
(1332-1406) considered the root cause of corruption to be the
passion for luxurious living within the ruling group. A new
manifestation in the history of corruption in Indonesia is the
role of banks in the intensification of corruption. More than
twenty years ago this was hardly heard of.

Coming back to efficiency, we must acknowledge that the
integrity of our officials is far from adequate.

A Dutch lawyer by the name of B.M. Taverne once wrote, "...
With good police officers, good prosecutors and good judges, but
an imperfect law, I still can achieve good results."

If this principle was included in our law then there would be
no need for creating new committees, and we could let the
existing legal institutions do the job.

SOEGIH ARTO
Jakarta

More from 12 December 2003 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/indonesia-is-1447899208-1330041)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print