Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Indonesia: How to restore confidence

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Indonesia: How to restore confidence

This is the first of two articles on restoring confidence by
Laksamana Sukardi, former state minister of investment and state
enterprises development.

JAKARTA (JP): Indonesia's general election of 1999 generated
tremendous promises and corresponding hopes. For investors --
both foreign and domestic -- the expectations were high as well.
It now appears that they were too high.

The new government has performed far below expectations. It is
interesting to contrast the transitional B.J. Habibie
administration with that of President Abdurrahman Wahid's.

People had fairly low expectations of the Habibie
administration because it was a continuation of Soeharto's New
Order regime. But in many ways the Habibie interlude delivered
more than many had hoped.

Despite overseeing a horribly violent withdrawal from the
occupied territory of East Timor, the Habibie administration
produced quite a lot of legislation, got the country through a
peaceful and relatively clean national election and ultimately
gave up power in a constitutional transition.

It could have been much worse, which is perhaps why
expectations were so low.

With the new government, everyone was swept up in a wave of
super anticipation. The first dose of reality came when the
Cabinet was announced. Investors either did not know most of the
economics ministers in the lineup or they had minimal confidence
in their ability.

The economics ministers were untested, mostly unknown and came
from different parties that had an established record of working
poorly with each other. How could this patchwork be pulled
together to respond rapidly to the challenges facing Indonesia?

This was a fair question to ask.

Indeed, the new government has not performed well, and we have
some quantitative indicators to back up this conclusion. The
Jakarta Composite Index has plunged from a level of 700 to the
mid 400s. With the obvious exceptions of Taiwan, Kuala Lumpur and
Hong Kong, this is partly a reflection of a regional pattern and
possible effects from the U.S. markets.

But the broad swings in the Indonesian case also reflects the
poor performance of the new government. The weakness of the
rupiah, which has dropped over 30 percent since the new
government came to power, provides further confirmation that we
are seeing a vote of no confidence from the investing community.

Successful Paris Club negotiations for rescheduling
Indonesia's massive sovereign debt and positive signals recently
from the International Monetary Fund have not been enough to
restore confidence in Indonesia.

What went wrong? Why has the new government delivered more
disappointments than accomplishments? Is it because the
pathologies of the previous regime remain in the system? Has the
virus of corruption been incubated during these first seven
months of the new government?

To answer these questions it is worth recalling what the
pathologies of the previous system were.

We were a country where rule of law did not exist. The
military shared power and benefits with a dictator. The dictator
issued decrees and the military backed them up with force and
intimidation. Meanwhile, our legislature was not a legislature.

It was a social club for elites that rarely even bothered to
go to their legislative chamber because they literally had
nothing to do.

Indonesia's courts grew more and more stagnant and corrupt.
Who needs judges and laws when laws and justice have no meaning?
Our courts became like Christie's auction house, where the items
for sale every day were the decisions of judges.

Instead of good governance we had a regime that did everything
in its power to break down the most fundamental institutions of
state and society.

Instead of transparency we had a murky system where most
information was either unavailable or inaccurate. And those that
wanted access to information of better quality had to pay for it.

Instead of rule of law we had a rotten legal system that had
all the external appearances of legality -- laws, judges and
courts -- but with no internal integrity and no predictability.

Instead of a developing civil society we had a systematic
dismantling of our social institutions. The signal was clear to
the whole society: either actively take part in the corrupt
patronage culture or get out of the way.

What was the result of all of this?

We had rapid economic growth that was unsustainable because it
was like building the Petronas Towers on a foundation of pebbles
and sand.

Although the Asian crisis began in 1997 in Thailand, it had
its most enduring and destructive impact in Indonesia. It hit us
hardest because we were the most vulnerable, and we have still
not gotten back up on our feet after the knockout punch.

Indonesia's banking system melted down completely and is still
far from recapitalization and recovery.

And equally destructive is the massive debt burden that has
been added to the backs of the Indonesian people. Everyone is
pretending as if Indonesia can bear this debt load and still
recover. But this is like whistling past the graveyard. The fact
is that we are now in a huge debt trap from which we cannot
escape without dramatic and creative action.

Unemployment is increasing, social instability is rising,
regional crises and killings continue and the government is in a
weak position to stimulate the economy.

As Vladimir Lenin once asked, "What is to be done?"

With regard to good governance, the point is not to design
some sort of grand restructuring strategy. Good governance starts
with the quality and standards of the people in decision-making
positions.

Although Indonesia has a rather plentiful supply of crooks and
thugs, the country also has plenty of good people available who
have a high commitment to good governance.

The key is to set the right standard at the very top of the
government, and then demand a selection process for officials and
top posts that is based on competence, skill, prudence and the
highest standards of integrity.

Of course, having the right people is not enough. Those
committed to good governance must be empowered to act as agents
of change. That is, they need consistent back-up.

Establishing a standard of good governance can be accomplished
overnight. But spreading that standard across the whole system is
not so simple. It's a struggle, a battle, a war. Those enjoying
unlimited access to power and money are not going to give up
without a fight.

But there is no hope of challenging them and their destructive
behavior if forces working for good governance are not seeded
into the system and given a chance to establish roots and grow.

So far, the new government has done nothing significant to
challenge the corrupt practices of the past. Many of the names
and faces are new, but everything else is just as before, if not
worse.

More from 22 June 2000 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/indonesia-how-to-restore-confidence-1447893297-1283652)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print