Indonesia Cannot Follow Japan's Tax Cut Move, Says Purbaya
Finance Minister Purbaya Yudhi Sadewa has no plans to reduce Value Added Tax (VAT) rates, even as several countries begin using tax instruments to support public purchasing power and economic growth.
This statement was made by Purbaya in response to the Japanese government’s plan to slash consumption tax on food products to 1% for two years starting in April 2027 to stimulate economic recovery.
“Not yet, but I will look into it; I am monitoring it continuously,” said Purbaya when met at the Ministry of Finance in Jakarta on Thursday (10/09/2026).
According to Purbaya, Japan’s policy cannot be applied directly to Indonesia. He explained that the tax cut in the Land of the Rising Sun is being implemented because of a slowing economic condition, necessitating additional government stimulus.
In Indonesia, the government continues to rely on various subsidy programmes and social assistance to maintain public purchasing power.
Consequently, the scope for reducing VAT rates is not as simple as it might seem. Purbaya emphasised that every fiscal policy must account for its impact on the budget deficit and the sustainability of national finances.
“It cannot be done. If it decreases, I will be accused of increasing the deficit; it is not that easy. Personally, I would want it to be zero, but if it were zero, we would have no money and there would be an uproar about us being in debt,” he remarked.
Purbaya stated that the government is currently striving to maintain a balance between driving economic growth and preserving fiscal health. He noted that while debt remains necessary to finance development, its growth must remain controlled.
“So we can finance economic growth, partly through debt, but we must ensure that the debt does not grow too large,” he said.
He warned that cutting VAT rates without careful calculation could potentially reduce the government’s fiscal space. As a result, the state’s ability to fund various subsidy and social protection programmes could also be eroded.
“Even now, there is a lot of noise regarding debt. If I reduce VAT and other things without proper calculation while the economy has not yet recovered, revenues will simply drop. I cannot provide subsidies without exceeding limits that are considered important. Therefore, we must weigh everything carefully,” Purbaya asserted.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/indonesia-cannot-follow-japans-tax-cut-move-says-purbaya-1789041846)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20260910170541-4-767008/ri-belum-bisa-ikutan-jepang-turunkan-pajak-ini-alasan-purbaya), translated from Indonesian