Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Indonesia-Australia ties: What went wrong?

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Indonesia-Australia ties: What went wrong?

By Hal Hill and Chris Manning

This is the second of two articles exploring the low ebb in
the Jakarta and Canberra ties.

CANBERRA (JP): Where do we go from now?

Recent experience has surely taught us that there are no quick
fixes. Unrealistic expectations of close bilateral relations,
frequently based on impractical hopes of commercial advantage,
built up in the 1990s, especially in the Keating years.

There is not yet enough commercial advantage on both sides to
make this a binding force. Nor is there a clearly dominant
partner in the bilateral relationship, or a long history of
previous conflict and learning to live together, factors which
have mitigated against conflict in recent times in countries such
as France and Germany, or Japan and China.

First, Australia and Indonesia need to work together because
of propinquity. It is easier to get on in the world, and in the
region, if there is no constant friction in one's own backyard.

This will not be easy. Leaders and people in both countries
need to recognize that, because of huge differences in 'initial
conditions' (economy, institutions, history, religion, cultures),
it will take generations to build the necessary broad-based,
people-to-people understanding. It will be a long time before
close and secure ties are able to withstand the vicissitudes that
are, inevitably, an occasional feature of the bilateral
relationship.

Arguably, Australia needs Indonesia more than the converse,
although many Australians balk at this proposition. (It rankles
with some that Australia, in spite its wealth and more developed
political institutions, must sometimes defer to its more populous
and internationally influential neighbor).

Australia is the smaller country and, in the eyes of many in
the region, the 'intruder' in Asia. Indonesia is a natural bridge
for Australia to countries in Southeast Asia and beyond. So the
ball is first and foremost in Australia's court.

Three special challenges face Australia. First, while there
are high hopes for democracy in Indonesia, Australians need to be
prepared for temporary setbacks, given the extraordinarily
difficult transition from such an autocratic regime.

Australia will need to achieve a balance here: between
affirming support for universalistic values, without seeming to
lecture when things don't go smoothly. The management of its
relations with Indonesia and other countries in the region
depends critically on Australia achieving a better balance here.

Certainly, Howard's bland announcement that Australia wishes
to promote and defend 'Australian values' in the region is not an
encouraging start.

Second, the fall of Soeharto, a much weakened military, and
East Timor's independence have increased the probability of
center-region conflicts which may threaten the unity of the
Indonesian state.

The case of Aceh is evident enough. The prospect of increasing
tensions in nearby Irian Jaya will require a sensitive Australian
response. As Professor Nancy Viviani recently argued at the
Indonesia Update conference in Canberra, Australia will need to
recognize fundamental historical differences in Indonesia's view
between Irian Jaya and East Timor: that is, a staunch commitment
to the former Dutch colonial territory as an integral part of
modern Indonesia.

Finally, there are bound to be on-going conflicts as East
Timor searches for a new political format, and seeks to promote
development in the shadow of its more powerful neighbours. We can
be certain that East Timor will remain more than a 'pebble' in
Australian-Indonesian relations, even with the best of possible
outcomes: a quick reconciliation and genuine efforts at
cooperation between the Timorese and Indonesian governments.

The bitter legacy from the armed conflict and human rights
abuse, and the potential disruption from cross border skirmishes,
will sorely test diplomatic relations. Avid supporters of the
Timorese case in Australia are likely to push for stronger
condemnation of Indonesia, or for Australian government responses
which could severely damage Australian-Indonesian relations.

This is not to argue, of course, that Australia should always
bow to Indonesian 'pressures', or to ignore the human rights of
the Timorese.

The bottom line is that Australia will need a new framework
and greater sensitivity on all these issues that remained
cocooned during the Soeharto years.

On East Timor, it seems important to establish a special
multilateral framework, similar to a donor's group, and ideally
involving Indonesia. This would help avoid conflicts which could
threaten frequent and serious derailment of Australia-Indonesian
relations.

A more democratic and open Indonesia can be expected to
recognize Australia's new challenges in relations with East
Timor. Relations with Australia will never rate high on the
Indonesian foreign policy agenda.

But Australia can be a valuable partner through its
considerable knowledge of and interest in Indonesia (and
Southeast Asia), and the density of people-to-people relations,
which are greater than with any other western country. It would
be hoped also that, in time, many more Indonesian leaders,
intellectuals, and ultimately politicians might appreciate this
potential.

In the immediate future, rather than sustaining a 'top-down'
special relationship, the task for governments is to work quietly
to develop deep and broad-based bridges across the Arafura.

The need is for quite modest initiatives, such as school
programs and exchanges, press interactions, and contacts between
the artistic, scholarly and professional communities in each
country. Australia's aid program should of course be maintained
(and not diluted to make way for assistance to East Timor),
including as a special feature a commitment to building
Indonesia's educational capacities.

Business ties should also be encouraged, although the 'cargo-
cult' mentality that appeared to develop in both countries (but
especially Australia) over the past decade should be hosed down.
Thus, in summary, maintaining good and productive relations is a
major challenge for our two governments.

People-to-people relations will be critical in getting over
the inevitable hurdles as we move forward, while recognizing that
the cultivation of a deep and broad-based understanding in each
country will take much longer.

For a still small number of Australians, Indonesia has been
the first engagement with a truly different, and enormously rich,
society and culture. Hopefully many more Australians will come to
appreciate this richness, and more Indonesians for their part
will benefit from deeper contact with the open and multiracial
society of Australia.

The authors are respectively professor of economics and head
of the Indonesia Project, Research School of Pacific Studies and
Asian Studies, and Asia-Pacific School of Economics and
Management, the Australian National University.

More from 1 December 1999 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/indonesia-australia-ties-what-went-wrong-1447893297-1421094)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print