In Minangkabau, L.C. Westenenk: A Wolf in Sheep's Clothing
In 1908, for the Minangkabau people, especially the residents of Kamang, the name Louis Contant Westenenk was no stranger. He was born in Penawangan (Demak, Semarang Residency, Dutch East Indies) on 3 February 1872 and died in Wassenaar in the Netherlands on 2 May 1930. In the colonial history of Minangkabau, his name is quite tainted and viewed negatively by the Minangkabau people because of his decision to send colonial troops to suppress the ‘Tax Rebellion’ in Kamang, which resulted in hundreds of casualties, dead and wounded (Yatim & Suryadi, 2026; 7).
One of his writings about Minangkabau is the book De Minangkabausche Nagari, published in 1913. The book was translated into Indonesian in 2026 under the title ‘Nagari di Minangkabau’. Like any colonial figure, he presented two faces: as a friend and as an enemy. As a friend, he would blend in and appear to fight for the interests of the local community. He would be interpreted as an enemy when carrying out his colonial policies. That position would cast him as a betrayer of the very people he had drawn close to.
To address the above, the author uses the book Nagari di Minangkabau as the source of analysis in this article. In his book, Westenenk discusses the conditions and problems facing the nagari at that time. As an orientalist, Westenenk also recounted the good deeds he had done. He contributed to advancing the economy and the thinking of the native sons of Minangkabau, and later promoted tourist destinations in the Minangkabau interior (Yatim & Suryadi, 2026; 7-9).
His colonial face began to show when he promoted night markets, popularised horse racing and issued requirements for the establishment of a nagari in Minangkabau. At first glance, Westenenk’s ideas appeared to serve the welfare of the Minangkabau people, but behind them lay concealed Dutch interests. For example, the profits from the night market, first held in Fort de Kock in 1906, were intended to showcase the agricultural, livestock and handicraft produce of the Minangkabau people.
The profits from the night market were used to send several local Minangkabau leaders on comparative study trips to Java. According to his account, there were three (sic) people who undertook the trip: 1) Datuak Batuah (head laras of Tilatang); 2) Datuak Bandaro Panjang (head laras of Banuhampu); 3) Datuak Kayo (head laras of IV Koto); and 4) Mas Warido (a Javanese descendant of Sentot Alibasyah’s deserters who became a Class 1 Coffee Mantri in Tilatang and Deputy Laras of Magek and Salo; he was later killed in the Kamang rebellion).
The four men sent by Westenenk to Java were Dutch stooges, since laras was a position for natives created by the Dutch, tasked with implementing colonial policies in the field. This means that the people sent by Westenenk on the study trip were not detached from Dutch interests themselves, while their travel costs came from the earnings of the native population.
Westenenk also claimed credit for popularising horse racing as a form of entertainment for the Minangkabau people, especially in the darek region. The best-known horse racing arenas were in two places: Bukit Ambacang in Agam and Bukit Gombak in Tanah Datar. According to the tambo, Agam’s animal symbol is the tiger, whilst Tanah Datar’s is the cat. The people of Agam are described as stubborn, brave and fond of fighting, whilst the people of Tanah Datar are friendly, patient, peace-loving, and kill without bloodshed, just as a cat catches a mouse.
The Dutch saw these two animal symbols as typical of the people of Agam and Tanah Datar. The easiest place to provoke their emotions was the horse racing arena, because it was also often used as a venue for gambling by spectators. Usually, the losers would often stir up trouble. Frustration was frequently vented on the winners.
Brawls at the racing arena would escalate into cakak banyak (mass fights). The adat philosophy of ‘standing in the village to protect the village’ would become the trigger for conflicts between villages. For the Dutch, such fights were highly advantageous, as they could prolong disputes between village communities. Regarding the fighting grounds, Westenenk (2026; 69) also wrote that one part of the open ground in a nagari was designated as a battlefield where adat wars or stone wars could be conducted. This means the seeds of cakak banyak already existed in Minangkabau before the arrival of the Dutch. Therefore, one way the Dutch stirred up fights between villages was through the horse racing arena.
Meanwhile, the symbol of the 50 Kota region is the wild goat; its people are typically gentle, patient, calm and peace-loving. Every problem in this region was usually resolved through deliberation (musyawarah), so the Dutch did not need military force to settle problems there. Just as wild goats fight by butting heads, the people would debate to defend their opinions, each using their own way of thinking. This character was the reason the Dutch did not promote horse racing arenas in the 50 Kota region.
Based on the typical character of the people of Agam and Tanah Datar, the Dutch decided it was necessary to build defensive fortresses: Fort de Kock in Agam and Van der Capellen in Tanah Datar. These forts functioned as strongholds in the event of attacks from the local population.
A further hidden mission issued by Westenenk in Minangkabau concerned the requirements for establishing a settlement there. The concept of a negeri offered by Westenenk was: having rice fields and farmland, swiddens and their drainage, hamlets and galanggang grounds, ducks and chickens, children and nephews, buffalo and goats, tabek and taman, korong and kampuang — that is the greatness of a nagari (Westenenk, 2026; 73). Based on this account, Westenenk did not include the mosque as one of the essential requirements for establishing a negeri in Minangkabau.
This was because Westenenk knew full well that for the Minangkabau people the mosque was not merely a place of worship; it could also serve various other functions. Therefore, in his book De Minangkabausche Nagari, Westenenk did not list the mosque among the requirements for founding a negeri, because he had learned from the experience of the Padri War, the Kamang War and the tax rebellion in Lintau Buo in 1908, in which mosques served as places to plan strategies against the Dutch. As a result, the Dutch faced great difficulty confronting them, for in the minds of the fighters, resisting the colonisers was a form of jihad in the way of Allah.
In closing, although L.C. Westenenk did contribute to promoting various economic activities of the Minangkabau people, as a Dutchman in the colony he served, he always remained loyal to his own country. As Edward Said put it, the Western world has never viewed the Eastern world objectively.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/in-minangkabau-l-c-westenenk-a-wolf-in-sheeps-clothing-1784883176)
Originally published by Republika (https://retizen.republika.co.id/posts/773128/di-minangkabau-l-c-westenenk-musang-berbulu-domba), translated from Indonesian