In Asia, pollution spreads as economies boom

In Asia, pollution spreads as economies boom

Jason Szep
Reuters
Singapore

Every two years, Indonesia loses about four million hectares of
forest, an area roughly the size of Switzerland, to rapacious
logging.

Skies in northern China glow orange in sandstorms that cross
the Pacific and lay dust on the western United States. In Hong
Kong, raw sewage bobs in its pearl-blue harbor.

From inner Mongolia to the Indian subcontinent and tropical
Southeast Asia, says one senior United Nations environmental
official, the region's ecology and environment is deteriorating
as its factories and economies boom.

Although governments are rolling out unprecedented initiatives
to tackle Asian pollution -- underscored by a meeting of
Southeast Asian environment ministers in mid-December in Myanmar
-- the policies are often badly enforced, the official adds.

"Things could get worse before they get better," Ravi Sawhney,
director of the environment and sustainable development division
of the United Nations Economic and Social Commission for the
Asia-Pacific, or UNESCAP, told Reuters in an interview.

Sawhney is studying Asia's environment for the UN State of the
Environment Report released every five years. Although the next
report is not due until 2005, Sawhney said indications point to a
broad-based worsening in environmental conditions.

"There are policy initiatives that have been taken and laws
enacted and so on. But the problem is the actual implementation,"
he said.

As if to highlight what he says, landslips and mudslides as
recently as November and mid-December in corners of Indonesia and
the Philippines plagued by illegal logging swept away or buried
alive whole families.

Six of the world's 15 most polluted cities are in Asia, and
the region generates a third of the world's carbon dioxide
emissions. In Asia's developing regions, around 785 million
people lack regular access to safe water, UN statistics show.

But there are pockets of improvement.

The air quality in notoriously polluted Bangkok, Dhaka, New
Delhi and several Chinese cities is healthier after most of Asia,
except for Indonesia, phased out lead from gasoline, said Cornie
Huizenga of the Asian Development Bank's Clean Air Initiative.

Bangladesh, which is spending US$30 million over two years to
bring natural gas to 100 petrol stations, is replacing high-
polluting two-stroke engines in its rickshaw taxis in the capital
Dhaka with cleaner-burning natural gas power.

"It's an unequal picture. There are cities where the situation
is getting better," said Huizenga, adding that a growing number
of cities have put up air monitoring systems.

Thailand's "tuk tuk" taxis now run on liquefied petroleum gas,
while buses and taxis in New Delhi and Bombay are phasing out
diesel and running instead on compressed natural gas. "This is
very much the story of the future," he added.

Huizenga and other environmental experts helped the
Association of South East Asian Nations (ASEAN) draw up an anti-
pollution plan as rising wealth brings demands for better urban
conditions after decades of squalor in some countries.

Southeast Asian Environment Ministers meeting in Myanmar
approved a non-binding "framework" which calls on ASEAN to
develop stronger urban anti-polluting strategies beginning with a
series of workshops next year.

"Due to rapid growth, you're getting overlapping problems --
water, air, land -- on top of each other, making a very complex
situation," said Peter Marcotullio, a researcher in the Institute
of Advanced Studies at the United Nations University in Tokyo.

"So part of what is being done here is to tease out some of
these problems so that city managers can deal with them one at a
time, as opposed to what seems to be happening is that they are
all coming at them at the same time."

Fixing Asia's environmental mess -- from stifling sandstorms
and rapid soil erosion in China to treating sewage in Indian
rivers and Southeast Asian air pollution -- is turning into a
billion-dollar business.

U.S. Department of Commerce is sending an "Environmental
Technologies" trade mission to Malaysia, Thailand and Vietnam
next March to scout for opportunities for U.S. companies, citing
"significant" potential for U.S. expansion.

It estimates that Malaysia's "environmental" market is worth
around $800 million, mostly for safe water supply and sewage
treatment, and says Thailand needs to spend around $1.2-$1.5
billion on clean water and sanitation by 2020.

In Vietnam, a pollution control equipment and services market
was worth $450 million in 2003 alone, it said.

Other environmental problems, however, are festering.

In Indonesia, home to the world's third-largest tropical
forests after Brazil and the Congo, forests have disappeared at a
rate three to four times faster than those in Brazil since 1990,
mostly because of logging and burning, says international
environmental group Global Forest Watch.

"Every year the country is losing nearly two million hectares
of forest. If this rate continues then by 2010 most forest in
Sumatra and Kalimantan will disappear," Longgena Ginting, head of
local environmental group Walhi, told Reuters, referring to two
of Indonesia's biggest islands.

Much of this feeds huge demand for timber in economically
booming China where logging was banned after excessive tree-
felling contributed to floods that killed around 4,000 people in
1998.

Chee Yoke Ling of the Third World Network, a Malaysian lobby
group, said countries such as Malaysia had nice-sounding
environmental laws but fell down on implementation, as damage to
tropical forests in Borneo's Sarawak and Sabah states continues.

"We have it but we don't enforce it," she said.

Chinese sandstorms are widely attributed to over-grazing,
over-ploughing and over-use of water resources.

ASEAN's "Framework on Environmentally Sustainable Cities" uses
some European cities as a model and is partly funded with German
taxpayer money through the Hanns Seidel Foundation.

"We had the same problems in Europe years ago, starting 30
years ago with completely poisoned lakes, rivers, in Germany,
poisoned air," said Waldemar Mathews, managing director of the
Bavarian Institute of Applied Environmental Research and
Technology. "And we started with the same discussions."

ASEAN groups Brunei, Malaysia, Indonesia, Vietnam, Singapore,
Laos, Cambodia, the Philippines, Myanmar and Thailand.

(Additional reporting by Tomi Soetjipto and Olivia Rondonuwu
in Jakarta, Patrick Chalmers in Kuala Lumpur and Maria Abraham.
in New Delhi)