Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

IMF Reveals Subsidies Can Cost Six Times More Than Social Aid

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
IMF Reveals Subsidies Can Cost Six Times More Than Social Aid
Image: CNBC Indonesia

IMF Reveals Subsidies Can Cost Six Times More Than Social Aid

Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia – The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has concluded that temporary, well-targeted direct assistance from the government is more effective than price subsidies in protecting poor households from sharp increases in the cost of basic necessities.

The IMF considers such policies important amid the threat of high inflation and a slowdown in the global economy. The cost of everyday needs, from food and electricity to fuel, has risen sharply over the past five years.

The price increases have been driven by disruptions in global commodity markets, from Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022 to the conflict in the Middle East this year.

Amid this cost-of-living crisis, the prices of basic necessities such as food and energy have risen faster than the prices of other goods and wage growth.

The IMF believes this situation is a serious concern because households find it difficult to reduce their consumption of essentials or to replace them with alternatives. As a result, price surges, even if temporary, can place significant pressure on households.

“People are facing not only temporary spikes in food and energy costs, but also a prolonged decline in purchasing power for essentials compared with other goods,” the IMF wrote, as quoted on Thursday (8/10/2026).

Such conditions could ultimately threaten macroeconomic stability. A prolonged fall in purchasing power for essentials can intensify economic pressure on the public.

In addition, inflation expectations have risen and remained above pre-crisis levels for years. This could make it harder for the central bank to control inflation through monetary policy.

Social Assistance Must Be Well-Targeted

According to the IMF, well-targeted, temporary transfers are the most effective and cost-efficient way to protect poor households when the prices of basic necessities surge.

Such policies can directly help the groups most in need while preserving government fiscal space. On the other hand, high market prices can still reflect scarcity, encouraging consumers to reduce consumption where possible.

“Assistance, if indeed needed, should be temporary and delivered through well-targeted income support measures; ideally, it should make use of existing social protection systems that can be rapidly scaled up,” the IMF said.

However, the IMF acknowledges that under exceptional circumstances, the coverage of assistance may need to be broadened.

These situations include acute concerns over food security, a rising risk of social unrest, or constraints in programme implementation. In such cases, support may be extended to groups beyond the poorest households and use broader instruments, as long as fiscal space allows.

Even so, the IMF stresses that support must be matched to the temporary components of price increases and include a clear sunset clause, rather than being based on permanent price rises.

“Even so, support must be matched to the temporary components of price increases, include clear sunset provisions, and not be based on permanent price increases,” the IMF said.

The size of assistance should also take into account the average impact of price shocks on low-income households, particularly when the coverage of beneficiaries is expanded.

If price intervention cannot be avoided, the IMF suggests that policies focus on goods and services that make up a larger share of consumption for vulnerable households.

Intervention should also ideally take place downstream and be designed so that market price mechanisms continue to function.

“In a world increasingly vulnerable to shocks, strengthening social protection before a crisis occurs can improve the effectiveness of future policy responses and help preserve the fiscal space needed to address shocks later on,” the IMF explained.

Subsidies Cost More

The IMF considers price-containment policies far less efficient than direct assistance because they require much greater fiscal spending.

“Such measures can ease the monetary policy dilemma in the short term by curbing inflation and preventing inflation expectations from becoming unanchored. However, they also demand significantly larger fiscal costs,” the IMF said.

Based on evidence from the IMF’s new modelling framework, providing the same level of protection to low-income families through consumer subsidies may require three to six times more fiscal resources than targeted transfers.

Subsidies to producers, meanwhile, are considered far more expensive. Their cost could reach 14 to 22 times that of targeted income support.

The IMF explains that producer subsidies work by lowering production costs, rather than providing direct support to households in need.

Such policies could even benefit foreign consumers through lower export prices of downstream products.

“As a result, taxpayers must bear greater costs to benefit society and businesses in other countries, rather than vulnerable families at home,” the IMF added.

(haa/haa) [Video CNBC]

More from 8 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/imf-reveals-subsidies-can-cost-six-times-more-than-social-aid-1791431568)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20261008094613-4-774326/imf-bongkar-biaya-subsidi-bisa-6-kali-lebih-mahal-dari-bansos), translated from Indonesian
Print