If Only Farmers Sold Rice, Not Unmilled Paddy
In a recent discussion, a question arose: is it true that most rice farmers in this country sell their harvests in the form of paddy? Yes, it is true. Most farmers, particularly those with small landholdels, sell paddy directly rather than rice.
They are not yet able to sell it in the form of rice. Why is this? There are at least three clear reasons for this phenomenon. First, the supply chain is structured this way. After harvesting, farmers usually sell paddy to collectors or middlemen. These collectors then gather the paddy to be taken to mills or rice factories. The mills themselves receive paddy from farmers as raw material.
Second, there are practical and economic reasons. Farmers require capital and equipment; milling paddy into rice incurs milling costs. Typically, farmers pay a milling fee of 10 per cent of the resulting rice. Not all farmers are willing to bear these costs and the risks of shrinkage or broken grains. Furthermore, farmers need immediate liquidity. Harvesting is synonymous with the need for cash to pay debts, purchase fertiliser for the next season, and meet household needs. Selling wet or dry paddy directly to collectors provides instant cash. If they were to mill it first, farmers would have to wait and find buyers for the rice themselves. Additionally, there is the risk and storage factor: paddy is more durable and less prone to spopering than rice. Small-scale farmers usually lack proper warehouses to store large quantities of rice.
Third, even Bulog (the National Logistics Agency) absorbs paddy. During harvest seasons, Bulog focuses on absorbing Harvestable Dry Paddy (GKP) at Rp 6,500/kg and rice at Rp 12,000/kg. This means paddy remains the primary commodity traded at the farmer level. However, there are exceptions: farmers with large fields and their own mills, or those who sell directly to consumers, sometimes sell rice. But for small-to-medium farmers, the general pattern is to harvest, dry into GKP, and sell paddy.
On the other hand, it is worth discussing more deeply why many farmers prefer selling paddy over rice. The advantages of selling paddy include rapid liquidity; a harvest in the afternoon can be sold to collectors that same afternoon without waiting in milling queues. It also requires no upfront capital, as there are no milling fees, sacks, or transport costs to consider. Furthermore, the risk is minimal: if rice prices plummet during the milling process, the farmer bears the loss. When selling paddy, the price risk is borne by the collector or the mill.
Conversely, the disadvantages include a lower price per kilogram. The 2026 HPP (Price Reference) for Harvestable Dry Paddy is Rp 6,500/kg. Approximately 1 kg of paddy yields 0.6–0.65 kg of rice. If rice is priced at Rp 12,000/kg, the paddy’s value ‘should’ be Rp 7,800/kg. Thus, farmers ‘lose’ that difference. Additionally, prices are determined by collectors, who often suppress paddy prices in the fields, leaving farmers with weak bargaining power.
What if they sold rice? This is usually done by farmers with significant capital or large landholdings. The advantage is a higher margin; retail rice prices range from Rp 12,000 to Rp 15,000/kg. The difference from paddy prices is substantial when selling directly to consumers or markets, and farmers can set their own prices without depending on middlemen. However, the disadvantages include upfront capital requirements for milling, sacks, and transport. Harvesting 2 tonnes of paddy could result in milling costs of around Rp 1 million to Rp 2 million. There is also the risk and extra labour involved: rice is easily damaged, prone to weevils, and subject to shrinkage. Farmers must also find their own buyers and may lack the time or network to do so. Furthermore, the process takes longer; from harvest, drying, and milling to selling, it can take one to two weeks, requiring patience to receive payment.
Critically, which option is ‘better’ for farmers? If the land is less than 0.5 hectares, quick cash is needed, and there is no transport available, selling paddy is certainly more practical and less stressful. The loss is small, but it is safe. However, if they possess their own mill or have access to cheap milling, selling rice is the better choice. The margin difference goes directly into their pockets. If they also have a network of markets or rice agents, they can sell rice at Rp 13,000–Rp 14,000/kg for higher profits.
What must be improved if farmers wish to sell their harvests as rice? It is entirely possible, but the government must intervene to resolve three main obstacles: capital, equipment, and markets. Steps have already been taken to improve capital and equipment so farmers can mill themselves. The primary hurdle is that farmers lack the funds to pay for milling and do not own Rice Milling Units (RMU).
What the government is doing includes: First, specific KUR (People’s Business Credit) for RMUs. The Ministry of Agriculture has prepared a Rp 300 trillion KUR, with RMU ceilings up to Rp 2 billion and interest rates of only 3 per cent per annum. The goal is for cooperatives, farmer groups (Gapoktan), or individual farmers to be able to purchase their own milling machines. Second, agricultural machinery assistance, including mini RMUs. This allows village cooperatives to operate mills so farmers can simply bring their paddy and pay lower fees or share the rice output. Third, simplifying permits: obtaining NIB (Business Identification Numbers) and milling permits is now online via OSS. Small-scale operations only require an SPPL (Environmental Management Statement) rather than a complex AMDAL (Environmental Impact Assessment). Logically, if a village has its own RMU, farmers will not need to rely on collectors; they can mill and sell the rice directly.
Furthermore, markets and prices must be guaranteed so that farmers’ rice sells without loss. Farmers fear milling paddy into rice because there might be no buyers. To address this, Bulog is absorbing rice, not just paddy. Since January 2026, Bulog has been proactively absorbing paddy and rice directly from the fields and mills. The rice HPP is set at Rp 12,000/kg, providing a guaranteed buyer. Additionally, the national SPHP 1 rice price for 2026 involves Bulog distributing SPHP rice across Indonesia to stabilise prices. This ensures a smoother flow of rice from surplus regions to deficit regions, so producing farmers do not struggle to sell. Finally, establishing the HPP for paddy at Rp 6,500/kg serves as a benchmark to prevent collectors from suppressing prices. Strengthening farmer institutions is also vital, as acting alone is difficult; therefore, the government is providing support through…
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/if-only-farmers-sold-rice-not-unmilled-paddy-1783471891)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/tht9cf472/andaikan-petani-jual-beras-bukan-gabah), translated from Indonesian