Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

IDX Demutualisation: Protecting Market Integrity and Independence

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Regulation
IDX Demutualisation: Protecting Market Integrity and Independence
Image: CNBC Indonesia

For almost three decades, Indonesia’s capital market has resembled a quiet, exclusive pavilion. Under Law No. 8/1995, the Indonesia Stock Exchange (IDX) was a “brokers’ club” — a mutual association in which exchange members were both owners and participants, with no dividends and no outside interference.

But time never stops knocking. Through the P2SK Law and now OJK Regulation No. 13/2026, those boundaries have been dismantled. We are witnessing a major transition: from a closed association to an open commercial entity in which strategic investors, the public and even state institutions such as Danantara, the Ministry of Finance and Bank Indonesia may take seats at the shareholders’ table.

This is not a betrayal of history, but a response to the demands of the times. Demutualisation is an effort to bring the exchange into step with the world’s financial centres. History shows that exchanges which fail to transform will be left behind in the dust of innovation. Let us look again at the experience of those who have already crossed this bridge.

The dark side of demutualisation: risks of political intervention and oligarchy

Commercialising an exchange can improve capital efficiency and technology, but without carefully designed safeguards it carries three interconnected systemic risks that could undermine market confidence.

The first is the spectre of monopoly and political intervention arising from the entry of state entities such as Danantara, the Ministry of Finance and Bank Indonesia. The concern is that the exchange could become a political instrument or be dictated to by the short-term agenda of the government in power.

To address this threat, OJK Regulation No. 13/2026 establishes a first line of defence by capping share ownership at 5% per party, including beneficial owners and affiliates, and strictly prohibiting anyone from becoming a majority shareholder (more than 50%).

Ownership above 5% requires OJK’s rigorous approval, based on the value it would bring to the exchange. OJK is also equipped with an “emergency button” — a disqualification event that can revoke voting rights or compel a share transfer if control becomes concentrated.

Ownership limits help prevent a monopoly on power. But they raise the second issue: a conflict between commercial motives (for-profit) and the exchange’s supervisory function, as a self-regulatory organisation (SRO). Under pressure to deliver returns to shareholders, the exchange could risk going soft on listed companies or lowering listing standards to boost listing-fee income and dividends.

To prevent this, OJK Regulation No. 13/2026 establishes a second line of defence by requiring a clear separation of leadership structures: directors responsible for regulatory functions may not also hold business or supervisory responsibilities.

This separation is reinforced through mandatory technological “Chinese walls” to isolate sensitive supervisory information from business units. The IDX must also establish and set aside annual operational and development reserves before distributing net profits as dividends.

With commercialisation and internal supervision tightly controlled, a third issue arises: the risk of discrimination against, and marginalisation of, small and local brokers. Separating share ownership from membership rights raises concerns that large securities firms or major shareholders could receive preferential access or fee discounts, undermining competition for local retail securities firms.

OJK Regulation No. 13/2026 closes this gap with a third line of defence, clearly separating share ownership from membership rights. It requires the IDX to provide trading access to all exchange members independently, transparently, fairly and without discriminatory fees. No matter how large an entity’s shareholding, it will receive neither preferential treatment nor discriminatory tariffs in the market.

Together, these three layers of protection regulate the process: they curb political control at the ownership level, contain conflicts of interest within the board of directors, and ensure a level playing field for all market participants in day-to-day operations.

Ultimately, capital markets are built on trust. Demutualisation is inevitable, but efficiency must not come at the expense of ethics. PROPAMI, as a professional organisation for the capital markets, considers professional standards and a strong GRC (Governance, Risk and Compliance) framework non-negotiable.

We want an IDX that is financially robust while continuing to stand firm as a fair referee. With a strong regulatory framework in place, this bastion of integrity must remain secure, ensuring that our market remains a garden for inclusive growth, rather than merely a battleground for fleeting political interests.

More from 9 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/idx-demutualisation-protecting-market-integrity-and-independence-1791535872)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20261009150601-14-774801/demutualisasi-bei-menjaga-benteng-integritas-pasar-dan-independensi), translated from Indonesian
Print