IDI Flags Criminalisation of Doctors in Pangkalpinang Case
The Executive Board of the Indonesian Medical Association (PB IDI) has highlighted the criminal charges against Dr Ratna Setia Asih, who faces a 4.6-year prison sentence following allegations of negligence that resulted in the death of a patient, Aldo Ramdani, during treatment at RSUD Depati Hamzah, Pangkalpinang. IDI considers this an act of criminalising the medical profession.
PB IDI maintains that the use of expert witnesses by the public prosecutor is inappropriate, as they do not meet the necessary criteria under medical law. These criteria include having equal competence, similar experience or years of service, working in a Regional General Hospital (RSUD) of the same type, and operating under similar time and environmental conditions.
The General Chairman of PB IDI, Slamet Budiarto, stated that if Dr Ratna is found guilty and sentenced, it could impact medical services throughout Indonesia. There are concerns that doctors may refuse ‘on-call’ consultations outside of working hours, ultimately disadvantaging the public and patients.
“Efforts for coaching and the application of administrative or other sanctions should be prioritised over criminal sanctions. IDI hopes that Dr Ratress will be acquitted of the criminal charges,” said Slamet on Thursday (18/6).
The Professional Discipline Council (MDP) has advised caution when providing recommendations to law enforcement to prevent the criminalisation of doctors. The council suggests prioritising professional discipline trials for alleged violations that result in patient loss. Recommendations from the MDP should only be issued in cases of medical criminal acts, and coordination with the Indonesian Medical Ethics Committee (MKEK) should occur before disciplinary proceedings.
“In presenting experts, they must meet the criteria of having equal competence, similar experience, working in health facilities of the same type, and working under similar time and place conditions. Law enforcement, the police, and the prosecution must not use MDP recommendations as the sole piece of evidence to criminalise doctors.
“Priority should be given to administrative resolutions (ethics/professional discipline) in medical dispute cases, rather than through criminal proceedings,” he added.
Meanwhile, the MDP has also sent a message to the Minister of Health to establish a Supervisory Board for the MDP to ensure its decisions are just. Furthermore, the council seeks legal protection for doctors across Indonesia who provide on-call consultation services outside of standard working hours.
“IDI urges the public to understand the medical profession’s approach to patient care, where services are provided as a maximum effort based on medical science, without promising specific results (no guarantee of a cure),” he concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/idi-flags-criminalisation-of-doctors-in-pangkalpinang-case-1781779878)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/humaniora/901809/kasus-dr-ratna-di-pangkalpinang-idi-kriminalisasi-profesi-dokter), translated from Indonesian