IDAI Files Amicus Curiae in Dr Ratna Case, Demands End to Criminalisation of Doctors
Public doubts must be answered through a transparent legal process.
The Indonesian Paediatric Society (IDAI) has formally submitted a brief of friends of the court, or amicus curiae, in criminal case number 295/Pid.Sus/2025/PN Pgp concerning the defendant dr. Ratna Setia Asih, Sp.A, at the Pangkalpinang District Court. The step was taken as a form of moral, scientific and legal concern to ensure that a medical case is not decided on the basis of assumptions or oversimplification of complex clinical issues.
IDAI believes the case has far-reaching implications for the future of legal protection for medical professionals in Indonesia. If adverse medical events are prosecuted without robust scientific proof, there is a fear that medical practice will fall under the shadow of criminalisation, damaging the climate of national healthcare services.
In the amicus curiae signed by 4,061 friends of the court, IDAI sets out a number of fundamental facts. First, the patient’s condition (Ananda AR) was a complex clinical case with severe comorbidities, namely Total AV Block — the highest degree of cardiac electrical conduction disorder, which can trigger sudden cardiac arrest.
Second, the patient was treated by a multidisciplinary team involving paediatric specialists and cardiologists. Therefore, placing the entire blame for the death on a single doctor is regarded as a flaw in both medical and legal logic.
“A doctor must not be punished for a poor medical outcome if there is no scientific evidence establishing a causal relationship between the doctor’s actions and the patient’s death. Criminal law must not rest on assumptions alone,” said the Chairperson of IDAI’s Central Board, Piprim Basarah Yanuarso, on Wednesday (14/7).
Piprim also highlighted the absence of an autopsy in this case. Without a post-mortem examination, the cause of death cannot be objectively established. Punishing a doctor without autopsy evidence is considered to eliminate the element of causation (conditio sine qua non), which is an absolute requirement in a negligence indictment.
IDAI Secretary General Hikari Ambara Sjakti added the importance of applying the principle of in dubio pro reo. “Given that the trial has not been able to prove that the defendant’s negligence was the direct cause of death, the panel of judges is obliged to rule in the manner most favourable to the defendant,” said Hikari.
Furthermore, the amicus curiae refers to the new paradigm under the National Criminal Code and Law Number 20 of 2025, which provides firm legal protection for medical professionals acting in good faith. A doctor cannot be criminalised for medical outcomes stemming from a patient’s pre-existing illness if the treatment complied with professional standards.
The Chairperson of IDAI’s Member Development and Defence Board (BP2A), Aryono Hendarto, stated that the support involved 4,061 friends of the court from 34 IDAI branches across Indonesia, from Aceh to Papua. The composition includes professors, full professors, and consultants in cardiology and neonatology sub-specialties.
“This case will become an important precedent. Will doctors work with professional courage, or instead with fear because every medical risk could turn into a criminal case,” said Aryono.
Through this document, IDAI requests that the panel of judges declare the charges against dr. Ratna Setia Asih legally unproven and hand down a full acquittal (vrijspraak). IDAI believes that justice for patients must not be achieved by sacrificing doctors through weak and unscientific proof.
The Indonesian Medical Association (IDI) considers the criminal charge against dr. Ratna Setia Asih in Pangkalpinang to be a criminalisation of the profession that threatens the national on-call healthcare system.
The Executive Board of the Indonesian Medical Association (PB IDI) has highlighted the demand for a four-and-a-half-year prison sentence against dr. Ratna Setia Asih over alleged negligence, calling for a review of the Professional Disciplinary Board (MDP) recommendation and the ongoing legal process.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/idai-files-amicus-curiae-in-dr-ratna-case-demands-end-to-criminalisation-of-doctors-1784026263)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/humaniora/910792/ajukan-amicus-curiae-kasus-dr-ratna-idai-minta-hentikan-kriminalisasi-dokter), translated from Indonesian