Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Hundreds of Lives Lost Due to Design Flaw

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Infrastructure
Hundreds of Lives Lost Due to Design Flaw
Image: detikcom

The collapse of the St Francis Dam stands as one of the worst construction accidents in the United States during the 20th century, primarily due to a fundamental design flaw.

According to a study by geologist Tony Waltham from Nottingham, England, the dam was a concrete gravity-arch type. It was constructed in San Francisquito Canyon, approximately 80 km northwest of downtown Los Angeles, to support the city’s water supply.

The disaster occurred shortly after the reservoir was filled to capacity for the first time on 12 March 1928. The dam collapsed suddenly, sending tens of millions of cubic metres of water surging through the valley below.

The construction of the dam began with a massive concrete gravity-arch design. During the construction process, the height of the dam was increased by 6 metres (to a total of 62 metres) without widening the base.

As the reservoir filled, vertical cracks began to appear on the downstream concrete surface. Once the reservoir reached its maximum capacity (spillway level) for the first time, the leakage began to increase significantly in volume.

On 12 March 1928, dam keepers discovered a leak of turbid water flowing at approximately 75 litres per second. An engineer and his assistant arrived to inspect the site but concluded that the leak was merely surface erosion and posed no danger.

Disaster struck shortly after. Two minutes before midnight, the St Francis Dam suffered a total collapse.

Approximately 47 million cubic metres of water spilled across the valley, forming a flood wave 40 metres high, travelling at speeds of nearly 30 km/h. The flood wave devastated the small town of Castai.

The disaster claimed at least 432 lives. Most of the victims were residents of isolated settlements and agricultural areas along the Santa Clara Valley who did not have time to evacuate.

Causes of the Collapse

The collapse was caused by a combination of highly unsuitable geological site conditions and engineering design errors.

Two-thirds of the dam rested on rock containing fractures parallel to the direction of the reservoir’s water pressure. The site was also situated atop an area prone to ancient landslides.

Furthermore, the dam was not equipped with relief wells or drainage holes in the abutments to alleviate groundwater pressure. Consequently, the structural pressure caused the dam to fail.

More from 26 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/hundreds-of-lives-lost-due-to-design-flaw-1790413008)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8680232/ratusan-nyawa-melayang-gara-gara-salah-desain), translated from Indonesian
Print