Human Trafficking at Sea and the Challenges of International Cooperation
To become more effective, cooperation also requires a minimum level of consensus in recognising indicators of human trafficking, ship inspection procedures, data exchange, witness protection, and victim referral mechanisms.
Jakarta (ANTARA) - The greatest challenge in human trafficking at sea is not merely apprehending perpetrators, but encouraging countries with differing legal systems to cooperate within a single chain of protection.
This crime possesses characteristics distinct from land-based trafficking. Victims are often far from their home countries, working on foreign-flagged vessels, and are only discovered once the ship has entered the jurisdiction of a third country.
For example, a worker in the fisheries sector may be recruited in Indonesia through an intermediary, sign a contract that is subsequently altered, depart for overseas, and be placed on a vessel that does not fly the Indonesian flag.
Once the ship sets sail, the victim’s connection to their home country does not disappear, but Indonesia’s ability to intervene directly becomes limited. This is because the flag state—the country where the ship is registered and whose flag it is entitled to fly—holds jurisdiction over the vessel, while the port state holds authority when the ship arrives in its port.
Consequently, a single case can involve multiple legal gateways simultaneously, making the issue increasingly complex.
Addressing Specific Vulnerabilities
The International Labour Organization (ILO) notes that fishery workers, particularly migrants, are highly vulnerable to forced labour and human trafficking. They are frequently recruited through deception or coercion, trapped in debt bondage, work long hours for low wages, and remain isolated for months on the high seas. Additionally, the capture fisheries industry is classified as one of the highest-risk sectors for occupational safety.
The problem lies not only in the severity of the violations but also in determining the legal jurisdiction where the violations occur. Ships are constantly moving, recruiters operate on land, while ship owners may reside in another country. Labour recruitment agencies often have their own complex structures, compounded by money flows that traverse the financial systems of various nations.
When victims are finally discovered, some evidence may already reside within the jurisdiction of another country. This makes maritime human trafficking a matter of transnational crime governance. This issue demands international cooperation because the recruitment processes, acts of exploitation, perpetrators, vessels, victims, and evidence are all spread across different jurisdictions.
Each country, in truth, does not lack the laws necessary to handle human trafficking. However, the difficulty lies in connecting the laws, authorities, information, and powers that are scattered across multiple nations.
The Indonesian National Police, for instance, cannot summarily seize documents from a company’s office operating abroad. Similarly, investigators in a port state do not automatically have access to recruitment data in Indonesia. Every law enforcement action requires a valid legal basis and international cooperation.
The issue of evidence is also more complicated. In maritime cases, evidence can include employment contracts, messages from recruiters, payment records, crew lists, ship logs, voyage data, communication records, accommodation conditions, and worker testimonies.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/human-trafficking-at-sea-and-the-challenges-of-international-cooperation-1789645824)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5745711/tppo-di-laut-dan-masalah-kerja-sama-antarnegara), translated from Indonesian