Human Creativity Remains Key in AI-Assisted Filmmaking, Say Experts
Creativity born of human thought is still considered an essential element in making films using artificial intelligence (AI) technology.
AI storyteller and judge for the AI CineFest short film competition, Immanuel Manurung, said that although making films with AI appears easy from a technical standpoint, creativity is still needed to deliver strong emotion and narrative flow in a film.
“The technical side is no longer an issue. Nowadays our grandparents at home can also create AI content with the technology. But what can inject emotion into every frame, what can set the pace, even down to the editing — that is what sets it apart,” Immanuel said during an AI Cinefest discussion session in Jakarta on Friday.
According to him, the creative process does not stop once AI generates images or video. Filmmakers must still go through the stages of selecting the best parts from AI-generated content, arranging the story’s rhythm, adjusting the background music and sound effects, and determining the dialogue so that it matches the emotion they wish to convey.
He believes the ability to connect all these elements into a single coherent story is an added value that cannot be replaced by AI.
“The curation process of all that output is what ultimately becomes the final result. There is a thinking process about whether the emotion has landed, whether the story’s pace matches the backing track or sound effects, and adjusting the dialogue. That is what makes the result different from generic AI content,” he said.
“The first and foremost skill is the creative skill. Seeing the angle, injecting emotion, because that is what distinguishes us from machines. There is a soul in that video,” said Rifqy.
Beyond creativity, he also considers curation skills to be important. According to him, creators need to be brave enough to sift through dozens of AI-generated images or videos to obtain the best quality.
“The curation process is what differs from one creator to another. Many have produced a lot of videos, but are afraid to choose or discard results that are not good enough because they feel they have already spent money,” he said.
Rifqy added that creators also need to understand the characteristics of each AI model so they can choose the tool most suited to their production needs while also considering the costs incurred.
“Each model has its own strengths. Creators must know when to use a particular model and how to balance cost with the results they want to achieve,” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/human-creativity-remains-key-in-ai-assisted-filmmaking-say-experts-1786121603)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5685148/kreativitas-manusia-jadi-unsur-penting-dalam-membuat-film-dengan-ai), translated from Indonesian