Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

How sacred is the unitary state of Indonesia?

| Source: The Jakarta Post

How sacred is the unitary state of Indonesia?

J. Soedjati Djiwandono, Political Analyst, Jakarta

Indeed, doubts have been expressed on the ambivalence of
certain Western countries with regard to the Aceh conflict. Scott
Burchill, lecturer in international relations at Deakin
University wrote a piece for the Melbourne daily The Age on May
24 (Why is Aceh different From Kosovo?) quoting Alexander
Downer's remark that "renewed assaults by the Indonesian military
(TNI) against the Free Aceh Movement (GAM) cannot be stopped by
outside intervention because Aceh is part of Indonesia, and the
Indonesians are going to have to sort out these problems
themselves", while praising NATO's 1999 bombing campaign against
Yugoslavia, suggesting "it was not until NATO stepped in to fill
the void that a successful humanitarian intervention was
undertaken that stemmed the ethnic cleansing in Kosovo".

Why should the world respect state sovereignty in Southeast
Asia but not in the Balkans?

Burchill noted that "Facing persecution and ethnic cleansing
from troops loyal to Belgrade, a Muslim separatist movement in
southern Yugoslavia (with al-Qaeda links) persuaded the world's
most powerful military alliance (NATO) to bomb Serbia until it
surrendered its political authority in Kosovo."

But in Aceh, he noted that "a Muslim separatist movement
(without al-Qaeda links), which has already seen more than 10,000
of its nationals killed since 1976 in a struggle with forces
loyal to Jakarta, now faces an escalating military assault and
the prospect of 200,000 people being cleansed from the province.
Appeals to the West and the UN for assistance and protection are
met with either indifference or outright hostility."

He quoted Downer as saying that "The violence perpetrated by
the separatist movement is absolutely unacceptable," and Defence
Minister Robert Hill, whose military forces breached Iraq's
territorial integrity in recent weeks, saying, "Indonesia's got
the perfect right to maintain its internal integrity and we
regret those who are in armed revolt."

What many often forget is that in an armed conflict, it is
never easy to determine which side fired the first shot and which
side reacted in self-defense.

In recent history, there have been "nations" in the narrower
sense (ethnic, religious, racial, or a combination of some such
factors) establishing their own sovereign nation-states separate
from larger political units.

After the collapse of the communist regimes, the Soviet Union
split into different nation states. The same thing happened,
although accompanied by violence, to Yugoslavia and
Czechoslovakia. Long before that, Bangladesh (East Pakistan at
that time) split from Pakistan with moral support and
humanitarian aid from India in 1971. Interestingly, Indonesia was
among the first to recognize Bangladesh.

When Sukarno and Mohammad Hatta proclaimed independence saying
"on behalf of the Indonesian nation", nobody protested. The
majority of Indonesians accepted and supported it.

Yet it turned out later that many wanted independence from the
Dutch in their own ways, not under the Republic of Indonesia as
proclaimed by the founding fathers.

Thus leaders of a number of regions bowed to the Dutch urging
the establishment of their own independent states in the form of
the State of Pasundan, the Republic of East Indonesia, the
Republic of North Sumatra, etc., which, together with Sukarno's
republic, 15 in all, later formed the United Republic of
Indonesia at the end of 1949.

Some states had to be persuaded personally by Hatta, then
Prime Minister of the united republic, to join the new Unitary
Republic of Indonesia in 1950. Despite that Soumokil declared the
Republic of South Maluku shortly thereafter.

However, most leaders of the new unitary republic seem to have
taken national unity for granted. Sukarno's personal charisma and
his outstanding skill to deliver off-the-cuff fiery speeches,
full of rhetoric about being a great nation endowed with natural
wealth and diverse cultures, seemed to work well to maintain
unity, even at times when the country was on the brink of
disunity.

Then, in the second half of the 1950s, some leaders began to
question Sukarno's leadership, and set up their own Revolutionary
Government of the Republic of Indonesia (PRRI). The PRRI did not
intend to be separate from the unitary republic of Indonesia.
Contrary to the belief of some to this day, it was not
separatism. They wanted to replace the central government in
Jakarta, which they accused ostensibly of being too strongly
influenced by communists.

Times have changed. The world has changed. And people have
changed. They have learned. Many of the present generation of
Indonesians are not as submissive as those in older generations.
They are more aware of their rights. They are more open, critical
and independent. They have their own demands. They have new
values.

The older generation may find it difficult to come to grips
with this reality. The new generation does not accept readily the
values and mores of the older generation. They do not simply take
them for granted. They question these values.

One of these values that they now question is the merits of
national unity, for so long taken for granted by their elders.
What have they gained and benefited from the unity of this huge
but so diverse nation, unity for what?

National unity, like national independence and the
establishment of a sovereign nation-state, are just a means,
after all, a means toward higher goals: General well being,
equality, justice, individual liberties and fulfillment. To
maintain national unity by the imposition of uniformity, by
slogans, let alone by force or threat of force, is
counterproductive.

The strongest factor that will ensure national unity is
justice. Therefore, beyond the demand for independence on the
part of the peoples of certain provinces is the demand for
justice. Indeed, broad, effective regional autonomy will be a way
of fulfilling such demands.

But if they feel they have been cheated by past promises of
justice for over half a century, how can we expect them to
believe any more promises, especially now that the issue does not
seem to be given top priority with a sense of urgency?
This is not a recipe for rebellion or treason.

One may cite the case of the American experience. President
Lincoln, in the 1860s, waged a civil war for five years for the
integrity of the American federation. But it was not a war purely
in the interest of national unity. It was in the interest of
humanity and justice: the liberation of slaves.

Have we not learned from Eastern Europe after the end of the
Cold War? Again, this is not a recommendation for separatism.
Most of us have not become citizens of this unitary republic by
choice. We were born here.

Taking the benefit of a new era of greater openness, we may
ask ourselves: Is it it our preference to have a single nation-
state out of this huge but almost unmanageable archipelago -- the
largest in the world, with the fourth largest population -- but
governed by corrupt politicians, marked by abject poverty among
most people, by continued injustice, lawlessness, continuous
tension and conflicts because of seemingly irreconcilable
differences in ethnic, religious and cultural terms?

Or at the risk of being dubbed "blasphemous", to split
peacefully into two, three, four, or even five smaller nation-
states with greater chances and hopes for peace, prosperity,
equality and justice for all?

A slogan during the struggle for independence read: "We love
peace, but we love freedom more". Perhaps, the reverse may be
more appropriate, for peace presupposes freedom.

The position of the government has been that any solution of
the Aceh problem must be within the framework of the unitary
state, which is considered final as designed by the founding
fathers of the republic.

Such a way of thinking must have been the result of misleading
education and ossifying indoctrination by Soeharto's New Order,
well known for its distortion of history. There is no logical or
rational basis for such a statement.

More from 4 June 2003 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/how-sacred-is-the-unitary-state-of-indonesia-1447893297-1328153)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print