House of Representatives Responds to Proposal to End Automatic Grade Promotion in 2027
Lalu Hadrian Irfani, deputy chair of Commission X of the Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR), has responded to a proposal that pupils should no longer automatically progress to the next grade in 2027. He said the proposal could be reintroduced in view of the quality of education in Indonesia, which he described as falling far short of expectations.
He pointed to Indonesian pupils’ PISA (Programme for International Student Assessment) scores, which he said were also disappointing. PISA is a study that evaluates education systems around the world.
“We have discussed this with the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education. The government believes that the quality of our education today is far from what we had hoped. Our PISA scores in both literacy and numeracy are also well below expectations. Therefore, the policy of not automatically promoting pupils will be brought back,” Lalu said at the parliamentary complex in Jakarta on Monday (12 October).
He said Commission X must study the proposal thoroughly if it is formally adopted, to ensure it does not end up placing an additional burden on pupils.
“This programme must not be implemented without proper consideration, only to burden pupils in our schools,” Lalu said.
Lalu also outlined a possible approach, saying pupils would not necessarily be held back for an entire year. They might instead repeat particular subjects in which they were struggling.
“If it is implemented, the process could involve remedial classes and repeating certain subjects in which pupils are weak. There must be a well-designed scheme for this,” he said.
He stressed that although Commission X supported the proposal, it should first be discussed with President Prabowo Subianto.
“If this has to be implemented, or must be implemented because of its urgency, it needs to be put to the President,” Lalu said.
Earlier, Primary and Secondary Education Minister Abdul Mu’ti commented on the proposal to end automatic grade promotion from the 2027 academic year.
The proposal emerged at the 12th Indonesian Education Convention 2026 at Ganesha University of Education (Undiksha) on Friday (2 October).
Mu’ti said the ministry was taking the suggestion seriously. If the recommendation to change the policy became part of the convention’s conclusions, he said, the ministry was ready to follow it up.
“If this is approved and becomes part of the convention’s recommendations, we will certainly be ready to implement it,” Mu’ti said, according to a written statement quoted on Thursday (8 October).
Mu’ti said the change was needed to restore pupils’ commitment to learning. He also highlighted what he called the ‘RMS formula’ — ‘being diligent or being lazy makes no difference’.
He said schools should give pupils the opportunity to understand that learning requires effort. Pupils who are diligent, motivated and demonstrate progress in their competencies should receive appropriate recognition.
Conversely, pupils who have not met the required competencies should not automatically be considered ready to move up to the next grade.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/house-of-representatives-responds-to-proposal-to-end-automatic-grade-promotion-in-2027-1791809502)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261012183017-32-1414543/dpr-respons-wacana-siswa-tidak-naik-kelas-tahun-2027), translated from Indonesian