House Commission XIII Hears Complaints from Junior Doctors Over Withheld Professional Certificates
Jakarta (ANTARA) - Commission XIII of the Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR RI) listened to complaints from young doctors regarding the withholding of professional certificates during a hearing with the National Commission on Human Rights (Komnas HAM) and the Indonesian Young Doctors Movement.
“Since this is an educational matter, we are looking at this within the context of human rights in the field of education so that we can formulate relevant recommendations,” said the Vice Chairman of Commission XIII, Andreas Hugo Pareira, at the DPR Building, Jakarta, on Thursday.
During the meeting, a representative of the Indonesian Young Doctors Movement, Mika Wardani, stated that the fate of prospective doctors remains uncertain because their professional certificates are not being issued.
This issue is believed to stem from medical education regulations deemed unfair. Mika highlighted a new regulation, namely the Regulation of the Minister of Research, Technology, and Higher Education Number 18 of 2018 concerning National Standards for Medical Education.
Article 40, paragraph (1) of Minister Regulation 18/2018 stipulates that medical and dental professional programmes must be conducted for a minimum of two years and a maximum of five years. However, Mika noted that this new rule is being applied retrospectively.
“Why are those of us from the 2018 cohort and below being subject to this Minister Regulation?” she asked.
Mika explained that professional medical education is conducted during the clinical clerkship (koas) period. She stated that the prospective doctors whose certificates are being withheld have completed their clinical clerkship in no more than five years, and their cumulative grade point averages (GPA) are satisfactory, at no less than 3.00.
“This reinforces the fact that we have been declared to have completed the medical professional programme by the university. This letter is very strong evidence for us that we have finished, so why are our professional certificates still being withheld to this day?” she said.
She also questioned Article 36, paragraph (2) of Law Number 20 of 2013 concerning Medical Education, which stipulates that to obtain a professional certificate, students must pass a competency test. This competency test refers to the National Competency Test for Medical Education Programmes (UKNPDPD), which consists of a Computer Based Test (CBT) and an Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE).
“Why must we pass the competency test before our [professional] certificates are given? Is this not a logical fallacy?” she asked.
Mika mentioned that the article is ambiguous, causing professional certificates to be withheld for students who are retaking exams (retakers).
“To use an example, when we test a halal product, it should result in a halal certificate. Why is it that a competency test results in the withholding of a professional certificate? This is an injustice and our rights are being withheld,” she said.
She added that most retakers have already passed the OSCE portion of the exam, stating, “We have only failed the CBT portion.”
The withholding of professional certificates is said to have various impacts, ranging from being unable to participate in professional oaths and not receiving professional titles, to the threat of being expelled (dropout) from campus due to exceeding the maximum study period.
“We are unable to find work, Ladies and Gentlemen. We are now unemployed and becoming a burden to our parents. If we could obtain these professional certificates, even if we have not yet passed the competency test, we could work in other areas that do not involve direct patient contact,” she said.
This impact is not only felt by domestic students but also by foreign nationals (WNA) studying medicine in Indonesia.
“What is truly heartbreaking is that our foreign colleagues are currently unable to return to their home countries to obtain their medical degrees and sit for competency exams in their respective nations because their professional certificates are being withheld, even though they have completed all their professional medical education in Indonesia,” Mika concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/house-commission-xiii-hears-complaints-from-junior-doctors-over-withheld-professional-certificates-1781776637)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5613008/komisi-xiii-dengar-aduan-dokter-muda-soal-penahanan-sertifikat-profesi), translated from Indonesian